The issue is not black and white.
Oh but it is. There is plenty of supporting evidence on the forum, especially on the Medfet boards. Go and see.
It's the matter of taste and skills/IQ. E.g. the infamous snowpants posts (the remnants I found anyway) were typical drag crap, while many hard to believe abuse stories are well-written and entertaining. Tell me you came here for something other, than entertainment. Uhm... real medical advice? Food and music discussions?
Members join here for many reasons, not only one. They are looking for different things. Some want to discuss their own personal experiences - real ones - and read others' accounts of their own real experiences. When they are reading such threads, they no doubt find entertainment in reading the posts, but it changes to annoyance when they detect fiction contaminating the reality.
Others come to read fictional stories, which may or may not be realistic in content. No one will mind that, and many will enjoy it provided it is posted in the correct area and not masquerading as reality content.
Any discussion of food and music is only part of the friendly discourse present on the site. If you dismiss that, you'll find yourself outnumbered by those who enjoy the sense of community it brings.
Many here must remember a few voy forums: on RT, spanking, pediatric care and similar topics. There are also similar (fake) polls e.g. on tickle torture punishment (for kids). I enjoyed those a lot more, than the majority of "honest", but boring (not to mention off-topic) discussions here. Why not just go to Facebook or similar mainstream social network, if you don't post about kinks? Why not go to an official rape or abuse support board, if you think people post those memories (on a kinks board) to seek compassion.
Those who are happy with what Zity offers stay here as members and many make good contributions. This is a thriving community.
On the other hand, those who aren't happy here for some reason aren't compelled to stay. They are able to leave if they so wish.
Really... if you only see this community, as a place to hookup for IRL (in real life) meetups, typically to engage in a vanilla DL or BDSM (if not just get laid, since you have no kinks at all) politically correct FetLife was created just for that with its insistence on real profile pictures and no fantasies about being younger than 18.
*********************************
Again, you are generalising, and incorrectly so. Some might be looking for that, but the majority probably aren't. It can be seen on member profiles what individuals look for here, whether they seek playmates, relationships or not. This is not a 'hook up' site as such.
It seems to me that you are repeatedly complaining about what Zity actually is while wishing it was something else. But this community wants what it has here. I'm afraid your own personal wishes and preferences do not override those of the majority.
As a contributor, you could write stories that I'm sure would be enjoyed by many members. No doubt they would be entertaining and well written. Everyone reading them will understand that they are not meant to represent real events provided they are posted in the appropriate places among the 10 'New stories and text submissions' boards. You are obviously quite capable of doing that.
I also understand that your own particular set of interests might be rare even for Zity. Yes, that will be frustrating, and I also understand that.
But those who feel they dislike or cannot abide by the site's customs, ethos and rules are free to go and start their own site and set their own agenda. It's really that simple.