@FunnStrict said
@DrZ your statement is dependent on both parties being completely honest with no hidden agenda (a little cynical here)....
Yes, you will note I did actually say
It's why I keep saying people should always have honest discussions about a wide range of things, sex included as one of the major factors, to determine whether they are actually compatible enough to even contemplate marriage.
I didn't argue that even a long series of talks and negotiations between a couple was an infallible method of ensuring compatibility and future happiness. You are correct to say that interests strong in the present can change or wane as time passes. But I can guarantee it is sheer foolishness, and reckless, to plunge into a long term commitment with someone without even attempting to touch on those subjects and gauge the other person's attitudes. If there is no discussion, you are relying on blind hope that things will work out, and the chances are, both parties will end up disappointed. I'm probably more cynical than you are about that.
I'm also very familiar with how some will lie and manipulate the other person, try to make them believe certain things, to get what they want for themselves. I've seen it enough times. But I wonder how long a manipulator will be prepared to keep at it before they give up. Also, will they be able to maintain the deception long term without detection?
The time you have known someone also has to be an important factor. Personally I think seeing someone for only a year before even discussing marriage is way, way too short. I'd be suspicious of such fast movement. I would question it. I would have doubts.