Open or closed Enema bags ? Your favorite to arouse you.

After the bulb, I grew up with the red classic hot water bottle combo, hose, and either the straight “ kid's ” nozzle, then later, a douche nozzle that Mom had waiting for me. After seeing the full combo bag hanging on the towel bar over the toilet, made my stomach hurt. I later saw other other enema bags hanging from other kid's bathroom doors when I went to pee, and imagined my girl / boy neighbors getting an enema like me getting one.

Every kid growing up back in the 60's was no stranger to the enema, and we teased each other when if I / they were home from school where homework was sent home and asked if their Mom gave them an enema.

Got an open top bag enema from my Aunt while my parents went on vacation, and not feeling good. Of course… a good enema was in order. Never saw one of these before, but saw the soapsuds running down the side of the bag got my interest and excitement. At 10 she already had the douche nozzle attached.

I get horny over seeing either bags, but wondering what others remember or like.

For me they started with the open top reddish brown rubber bag that my grandmother (a nurse) used for what would become a weekly enema event for me. My grandmother had a lot of enema equipment, different ages, nozzles, hoses and including colon tubes and Inflated nozzles.

Mine are HWB-Style (Closed top) bags.

Only exception is my white 4-qt bag. Even then, I would have bought closed top if I had found a 4-qt!

My green bag that I use ONLY for the occasional douche, and nothing else, and that is probably the oldest bag in my collection is an open-top also

Our family ‘ fountain douche / enema syringe system ’ was always of the ‘ close-top ’ design as was also the syringe of choice in one of my grandmother's home from which I was often given a ‘ while visiting ’ enema . My other grandmother owned and utilized a ‘ tall enamel can w/ hose clamp and rectal tube(s) ’ for my occasional enema activities in that home . All were efficient as to purpose and I still own a ' closed-top ' enema syringe today . Just my preference .

Here we don't use them.

We have faucets / jet showers instead of tissues to wipe

I use that to clean myself up by filling up with water

The Victoria enema bag was the screw threaded hose adapter kind. Everytime a enema was announced--it was the first thing my eyes focused on as I entered the bathroom😬. Hanging there--awaiting me..@ the pre-measured 20" above my buttocks height (per Dr.) A semi-bulging look..sometimes with a little cloud of soapy bubbles hanging down around the neck of the enema bag. At age 9 -10 this sight gave me a jolt of goosebumps everytime. The ol' Victoria ‘closed’ enema bag gave my small body framed constipated butt a whopper of a enema everytime

Mom always used an open top bag as it was so easy to refill,she didn’t have to move it,she had a full pitcher of warm water to refill it as necessary and just keep me plugged into the nozzle!

Open tops here much easier to fill or add solution to

My Mother used a Rexall Victoria Combination syringe (closed bag) on me. It wasn't until I bought my own bag, without Mom knowing it, that I ever got an enema with an open top bag. Even, the one I bought with Mom's money in the drug store with Mom, while Mother was trying to embarrass me, was a closed bag exactly like the one Mom had cut up to stop me from taking enemas on my own… My preference is the closed type… hot water bottle bulging with water….

There's something incredibly exciting about the closed type bag….when filled to the max and bulging! It's how I remember seeing them as a kid. Just the sight of it made me weak in the knees. I knew I was going to get it GOOD!

Nothing looks better than a bulging large red bag, however, in sense of practical matters I prefer the open-top one.

The reason is that the hot water bottle type needs to be removed from where it is hanging while the open top can remain there for the whole session.

I always make the mixture in the kitchen and so the closed-top bag needs to be taken there all the time. For the open-top I pour the mixture into a pair of plastic bottles, take them to the bathroom and fill the bag there.

It is also a bit of struggle to hang a fully loaded bag properly and quickly. So, my vote goes for the open-top bags.

Open top.

You can add/mix solutions.

The red rubber OPEN TOP enema is the easiest to manage and prepare as far as mixing-in the solution. https://en.zity.biz/gallery/image/215099

I have 4 vintage bags.4 colors red.white.blue.green.2 open top 2 closed. closed top r my favorite because they go flat when they empty .but i like them all

As a child I got my enemas from mom with a bulb. The first bag enema I got, and for my teenage years after was with the typical red combo bag. The first bag I bought for myself was a Faultless Folding Syringe, with the yellow latex bag. As a young wife, I bought a new closed top combo bag to use when playing in bed with my husband because it reduces the danger of accidental spills. But for solo enemas nothing beats the open top fountain syringe for quick and easy filling and cleanup after. By far, the majority of my enemas these days is with the open top, even though I have the other kinds available too.

Definitely open top. It's just so much more convenient (and quick) to add more solution, etc.

I like closed top just because it is harder to spill. I do like the sound an open top makes as it runs dry though. Kind of a little squeak to let you know that the recipient will soon be squeaky clean!

Bulbs, open top, combination bags, whatever it takes for wet kinky enema play will do just fine😜

For strictly nostalgic reasons, a red HWB certainly. For convenience especially with regard to cleanup the new silicone open-top cannot be beat. Either way, I'm a happy camper.

All my enemas from childhood in hospital to solo or by my wife were applied with an enema can (irrigator): It is easy to hang the irrigator on a hook or place it on a solid horizontal surface and refilling during the enema is of no problem. Unfortunately, these cans disappeared from hospital use.

My first memories of moms enema bag was it was a light powder blue latex bag , not real big but when full would balloon out , the main thing I remember is the smell of the latex and to this day the smell still takes me back. For the last 30 plus years I have and use both open and closed top bags and like a lot of previous post they both have advantages and disadvantages, the red closed top combo bag is my favorite but the open top is easier to and more water without removing the bag from the hook if you feel like you want more but at the end of the day for me it’s all about the nozzle that is attached to either bag. The sight of a douche nozzle really gets me going

I prefer the closed / hot water bottle style, maybe because that is the style I first had seen and remember peeking at it and admiring it all my young years.

https://en.zity.biz/gallery/image/160953

That ^ is the exact set ^ in the image in the link above ^.

While I have both, combo bags and open top fountain syringes, I must admit that the open top is by far my favorite.

Why?

Being the reasonably practical person I am, I love the ease of filling and the ease of clean-up with the open top bag. Plus, I can visually inspect the bag to make sure everything is clean. As for the combo bags, I do love the visual stimulation of seeing it full to bursting with its contains straining to get out. But the disadvantage is the clean-up.

But the wonderful thing is, we have a choice…so I say, use whichever one gives you the greatest thrill!

Have fun and play safe!

Deb

The bag we had at home growing up was an open top. I had disposable enemas pretty often, but never a bulb. I think mom had cleanliness issues about bulbs (not being able to see inside), based on a conversation I overheard part of once. Mom may had not preffed closed bags for the same reason.

The first bag I had bought for myself had been an open top. I have owned a few of the closed “combo bags” too over the years, but I currently don't have one. I have a few open tops though, and if/when I purchase bags I go with open tops. I may invest in a bucket someday too.

I prefer the open tops mostly due to the fact that I can see inside it, and know that there is no mildew or nasty forming in any corners. I have a bulb, but it's a nice clear silicone bulb that I can see through and inspect after cleaning and air drying. I think if there had been transparent bulbs back then, mom might had opted for that approach. More economical in the long run for smaller enemas, reusable close alternative to the disposable.

I'm sure we've covered this topic someplace else, but it's great to read what everyone says here. My favorite bags - red 2.5qt Davol open top, Faultless open-top in pink; and oh, then there's a classic white Contessa… To a lesser degree, I like closed combo bags…

Love the sight of a bulging (backfilled) .full closed top enema bag.

Open top!

Growing up, the open top red bag with red hose, black bakelite nozzle, and metal clamp hung on the back of the bathroom door. That was the the bag that gave me my first enema at age 7. Would love to find one just like it. I have a closed bag now, which does the job … but would get more excited seeing the old open top doing the job!

Growing up we had a cĺosed top BF Goodrich Coronet syringe. It had a red hose, bag and black nozzles and i loved that bag. I have one now and it really brings back memories!!

I prefer open top. I do have one closed top but it is never used. I just find an open top easier to refill.