Open or closed Enema bags ? Your favorite to arouse you.

I have used both kinds over the years, the first 50 years ( child at home and most of adult life) of enemas were with a closed top, 2 qt. red bag. The last 10 or so have been with open top bags. The open tops are easier to fill, refill, and clean. Currently using a 4 qt. Seeking Health, open top, silicone bag. Another advantage of clear , open top bags is you can add graduation marks. With a timer and adjustable clamp, you can reproduce desired flow rates We also have a flow indicator inline, which my wife likes a lot.

As much as I like open-tops, when I was into taking large enemas the closed hot-water bottle bag was great for force filling to make it swell up to look like a large ball. The closed bag does go very flat, and thanks to it being sealed it looks like it's been vacuumed just so long as the vacuum isn't disturbed (if you seen it, you know what I mean)..

Open tops are just easier to use.

I have only had open bags but a Bulging full closed bag is def a tern on

Has to be closed because I like my bag on my chest and hug it sometimes.

I like my bag on my chest and hug it sometimes.

Often start out standing with my open-top foaming over while I hold it with both hands and press it to my face so I can feel it's warmth and taken in the scents of red rubber and Ivory… Works well when using a DBRN so that the enema can flow in at the same time without the chance of the nozzle popping out.

@debgurl While I have both, combo bags and open top fountain syringes, I must admit that the open top is by far my favorite.

My favorite, too. I have a long and (mostly) enjoyable relationship with my pink, open-top fountain syringe. “Pinky” has helped me through many health-related and even emotional times in my life.

I love a closed fountain syringe connected to a Higgenson syringe connected to a douche nozzle inserted just far enough inside so that the enema doesn't flow out and my girlfriend squeezing the bulb filling me with warm soapy water.

I have had both types (open and closed). The closed top bag was purchased from a grocery store in the late 90's. It was high quality latex but over time the screw top or bottom when the bag was placed on its hook did leak causing a mess. I dealt with the leaking issue by laying the bag on its side with the screw-in tube end draped over the sink to catch the dripping leak. It still worked as an enema bag, but that experience caused me to buy an open top bag.

I now have a 1-gallon Silicone open top bag. I have had it for about 7 years now and it is still going strong and works perfectly. I wouldn't have another closed top bag when the open tops are so much easier to fill and they don't leak. If you are buying your first enema bag or a replacement, I would highly recommend a closed top bag.

Have always used an open top bag with a Higgenson pump - easy to fill and hang from towel bar on shower door.

I prefer the open tops, easier to fill, clean, and dry out.

I love them both but i like open top because easier to clean and no worry of mold and that happens in combination syringes

My every day “go to” bag is a red open top. I take an enema every day.

When I want to stimulate a Harris flush, I use my old closed top and lie down. I love varying the water pressure (surges), raising and lowering the bag up and down as far as I can reach. A closed bag is the better choice for doing this. It does make me feel like I want to climax or lose the entire enema on the bed. (I've come real close. But it feels fantastic! )

@MomsEgirl - That's what bed pads are for! Go to Sam's and buy a bundle; use liberally under the “affected part” and quit worrying about a ruined mattress. Or, go to Lowes or Home Depot and buy the thinnest plastic painters' cloths, then make your bed with that under the bottom sheet. You might have to toss the sheets if you explode in the bed, but the mattress will be pristine! Also, that thin plastic sheet doesn't wrinkle and crinkle as you move in bed. In fact, you'll be the only one who knows it's there. Happy hosing!

While open top is the favorite around here, the sight of a combo bag can elicit revealing responses from someone whose orientation is unknown to you. A combo bag left in a bathroom may inspire someone new to you to offer “ I see you have a (hot water bottle, douche bag, enema bag) in your bath." The term chosen may disclose a lot about that person. Of course, most people will say nothing, but it's quite interesting if they do.

Open top so I can see the suds peeking out the top and dribbling down the side.

I like both open and closed. I have a small collection of vintage bags (Davol comfy, Davol Paris, Victoria Combo Bag and 2 Davol open top) I also have a collection of the black Bakelite nozzles. Off topic I also have a rectal thermometer with a pear-shaped bulb. It's the one mom used on my growing up.

Many of the different vintage enema and douche bags have some unique features that trigger different psychological reactions.

I've referred often to Victoria, who hangs around just waiting to provide some of those shits and giggles. It is nice to see her bulging. whether the fountain, combination, or folding variety. I avoid playing favorites.

US Rubber, Sears, Davol, Rexall, and others, each hold a special place when the urge is too great to ignore!

I grew up getting enemas from a combination syringe so after graduating from college and a place of my own I got one just like it. This was in a addition to the amber folding syringe that I used for douching, but sadly that only lasted about 20 years before failing. Much later, and I have written about this numerous times, I discovered a very nice porcelain enema can at a flea market. It's very convenient when preparing an enema or cleaning up afterwards. If it has a drawback it is that you cannot tell how much you've taken or how much left to go, but the best part is that I can leave it out in the open and nobody has any idea what it is used for.

I imprinted on an open top enema/douche bag growing up and so find that style to be the definitive “enema bag”. My first purchased enema kit was a combination bag (for hot water bottle use should it be discovered). Subsequent additions were open top styles. Present day I used a Seeking Health bag for my regular enemas and a Klystra silicone bag for colon tube enemas. When away from home I use a Eastern European HWB bag that holds about 2.5 USA quarts. Easy to fill, doesn’t require measuring and resists accidental spills if you remember to first close the shutoff clamp before inverting.

@Emom - That is unless that “nobody” is one of US and knows what a Jones can is all about!! (lol)

When my siblings an I were kids, mom used either a two quart closed top or a three quart pumpkin enema bag with the adult rectal nozzle. Grandma on the other hand, used either a two quart closed top or a 2½ quart open top enema bag with whichever nozzle was attached at the time. The two quart closed top bag with curved douche nozzle was primarily used, because that was the combination normally hanging in the bathroom shower. The open top bag was used occasionally, but mainly during her 3H enemas. I also remember her using her three quart pumpkin bag on me once, during a 3H enema when I was eleven.

The big difference between mom and grandma was mom gave us enemas together in the bedroom. Hence, her use of a three quart pumpkin bag, because she only had to fill the pumpkin bag once for our soapy enema an once for our rinse enema. When she moved our enemas from the bedroom to the bathroom, she switch to the two quart closed top bag. Grandma, on the other hand, gave us enemas in the privacy of her bathroom. There were a few exceptions, when she gave my brother an I enemas together a few times. Always using whichever bag and nozzle combination was hanging in the shower.

As to our favorite type of douche/enema bag that arouse us. There wasn’t one, because my siblings an I were all anal erotic. It was the enema itself that turned us on, not the enema bag. Did the enema bag play its part in getting us aroused, sure it did. But both types of bags did exactly the same thing. They held two or 2½ quarts of warm soapy enema or warm salt and baking soda rinse enema.

@Emom - That is unless that “nobody” is one of US and knows what a Jones can is all about!! (lol)

Needless to say most people would not. The exception being if we invited people from Zity to the lake house.

E-Party!!??!! (lol)

Although I have never had one, I would prefer the open-top fountain syringe bag so I could add more water to it when taking an enema without any trouble. Doing that with a closed top bag is a real pain in the you-know-where… the enema nozzle goes.

I found the old enema gear in the bathroom at age 11. It was the red bulb with a Bakelite black straight nozzle. I knew what it was for because of the enemas I received until about age 5. Well, you know I had to gI’ve it a try… yep, I was hooked! Further snooping through the cabinet revealed a douche bulb. Oh My! That was over the top wonderful. I discovered that The tip unscrewed for cleaning and I carefully cleaned it after each use. My enema kink was now Game-On and the rest is history. I was in my 20’s when I finally purchased a combination closed top bag and always used the douche nozzle. I now have a silicone 2.5 qt bag with a 20 inch colon tube that I use often. That would be my favorite one.

@emom, As for that Enema Can, you would probably be surprised how many people would recognize it for what it really is. “Say, that is such a cute flower pot you have! And it has a built in drain!“😊

My mom had a closed bag, this when I first started getting enemas from a bag, don't know the brand. A couple of years later she switched to a Faultless open top bag and used the douche nozzle. She only used the bag for enemas both for me and herself.

For the swollen enema bag look, I definitely prefer the closed top bag. I think it deflates in a more erotic fashion as the sides suck together, if that makes sense. I do like the ease of filling an open top and I like the gentle sucking slurp sound it makes when it’s empty

Our bags are all open top with the exception of one red closed top. That's identical to the one my mom used on me. Nastalgic reason to keep one around, although much harder to keep clean.

My Mom had a old Davol Comfy Combination bag. She started using it on me when I was about 6 . By then I wouldn't cooperate by laying there and letting her slide the bulb syringe in and out of me. She sold me on the idea that the nozzle only had to be inserted once.I still didn't like it much, but got used to it, In time I started to like it.

When I turned 13 I was ill & Mom decided I needed an enema. The bag had cracked while being stored and when Mom filled it, it was leaking all over. So what to do. Mom said she would go to the drug store and get a new one.

She came back & as there was no selection she said, they only had one style, it was an open top. Mom said they use to have many styles and brands. Now all they had was the one. OK no big deal. Mom tried but said she needed someone to hold it for her so she could work the snap valve and hold the nozzle in place.

When my sister came home from school she got the job of holding it. Mom told her when to raise and lower the bag to control the pressure. So here I am laying on my bed naked from the waist down with Mom holding the hose and opening and closing the snap valve, and my sister only one year older than me holding the bag. I was so embarrassed I wanted to cry.

So for me I would have to say the closed top combination bag was my favorite.