Open or closed Enema bags ? Your favorite to arouse you.

For the swollen enema bag look, I definitely prefer the closed top bag. I think it deflates in a more erotic fashion as the sides suck together, if that makes sense. I do like the ease of filling an open top and I like the gentle sucking slurp sound it makes when it’s empty

Perfect! Could not have said it better! Thanks

Since I was a girl, until today, I have always had an open model.

Mom had open top fountain syringe, then acquired a douche bulb.

i prefer the combo bag for less chance of spilling, but have both type bags and they get the job done.

Bulbs are always great too. More play than practical, but mood drives selection. Also alone or with a partner is a factor. The silicone bag is nice for watching the solution level drop, possibly a psychological plus or not. Enjoy!

I like closed. Then if they get tipped or fall there is a chance of no spilling (unless the lid pops open.) Famous last words…tempting fate I am.

I much prefer the open top bag, often called a fountain syringe, for everyday use. It is quicker to setup, fill, and clean. But, for stimulation and good memories nothing beats the old fashioned closed-top combination bag. That is what was used for my first bag enema, which I enjoyed and was a major contributor to my continuing use, and for the first enema I gave to someone else.

Like many, I started with the closed bag. But as I got more into enemas, I used an open top. Just more convenient for filling or adding liquids after the first two quarts are gone. I also like the slurping sound the open top makes when the last of the contents are exhausted. With silicon tubing, I also like to see the last of the solution drift down the tube before shutting it off. Closed bags the tube remains filled and never sure I got it all.

I started with the Artsana ones which are open, but now use closed 3L ones. I have had the odd spill before so closed are nice in that regard.

My preference as always been for open top bags for enemas.

If a person is seen carrying a filled hot water bottle, there is ambiguity about its purpose… someone may just have cold feet.

But, if you see an open top bag, which can't be used as a hot water bottle, it is certain someone is going to get an enema to make them poo very soon.

Of course, if the person carrying the bag is a woman, it is possible she's going to douche herself, but, I think, seeing this is unlikely because douching is usually a pretty private activity and women don't parade around carrying a filled douche bag.

Open top

Closed top (HWB Style) are just neater all around.

Less mess, less cleanup.

An open bag toppled and it created a mess, so we use closed bags.

Safety, yes for the closed bag but for our more careful users the sight of the bulging open bag with perhaps some suds falling from the top is unsurpassable. So graceful, so inviting, so threatening and there it is ready for us. Although the sight of a fully emptied closed bag which has delivered its warmth is to be admired also. To each his/her own is my motto in the enema business. Or as my auntie would say, ‘What pleases one will puke another’.

With mom, (me age 4 to 6 or so) it was always OTK with an “infant” rectal bulb. Hated them…didn't we all? Later, she used (not on me, but…?) a white enamel Jones cannister. When I became anal erotic and discovered the “sexiness” of enemas, I used my wife's feminine douche syringe (she bought it for me, not her…lol). I graduated to an open top from OHN and used it almost exclusively for quite a while. Then I discovered that a couple shots with a adult bulb syringe was good for a quick and pleasant cleanout…no muss, no fuss. Present day: while all of the aforementioned gear is still around and used (save for the infant rectal…long gone) I discovered a bit ago a nicely sized (12 -13 oz) bulb syringe (MikaCare from Amazon) with a 24 inch hose, nice mechanics, and a great douche nozzle. The most convenient thing I ever used…really great for solo “work”!!! So, is that open top or closed top? Whichever, IT's FUN!!!!

I use a gallon open top. I started out with a closed top, but as my capacity increased, the two quart bag just wasn't doing it. I now use the open top, as I haven't been able to find a clear gallon closed top, and it's much easier to add a bit when I want more than a gallon.

I like an open top for a nozzle enema and a closed top for an colon tube enema. ( which I am going to try for for the first time shortly)

When I am given an enema, I love for us both to watch the water slowly disappear from the bag… as we talk about our day to take my mind off of it.

As the bag empties, and is clamped off, then comes the wait, while we both enjoy knowing what I am feeling 😘

Shy🌟

I've been using open top bags for many years now. They're just much easier to fill, clean and dry. But the closed fountain syringe bags of my youth, red bag, red hose, black nozzle, have always been an erotic trigger for me. Many memories of mom leaning over the bathtub filling the bag for my second enema while telling me what a good enema I just took and how one more will clean me out real good, and then screwing on the hose………

Closed. Yes you can fill open tops quickly, but you can overfill a closed top, and get a nice blast of water, or you can wring every bit of water out of a closed top, and if you drop it, no water is spilled

My mom only used open-top bags; so nothings says enema bag better than an open-top red fountain syringe.

Open. I have a 4 quart bag and it's very convenient should I need a refill.

4 quart clear silicone open top for me. Easy to refill, clear so I can see my progress. Will use the antique red closed bag only when I am feeling nostalgic.

@ShyELover such an erotic reply. A real turn on!

My Mother was given a Rexall Victoria Combination syringe by my grandmother, her Mother, to give me an enema with. I had previously asked her to get Mother to give me one. When I got in high school I bought myself a Tyson 2 quart red fountain syringe for my personal use. I thought I had it hidden in the bathroom, but Mother found it And actually hid it from me. It took a lot of fortitude, but I did go and ask her if she had found it. Mom hemhawed around a bit, but eventually told me where she had put it. But, not before telling me that she wished that I would not take so many enemas. My response to her was “Mom, I like the way enemas feel as the water goes into me!” I remember Mother saying “Well, come on I’ll get the ”Thing” for you!

When I got in high school I bought me a Tyson 2 quart red fountain syringe for my personal use.

Hadn't heard of that brand name; so here's a link to google images for Tyson fountain syringe https://www.google.com/search?q=Tyson++fountain+syringe&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwj8_MXlsYD6AhUtD1kFHU3wBMEQ_AUoAnoECAEQBA&biw=1280&bih=775&dpr=1

I Have been using closed top with douche nozzle on my wife for a couple of years now. Recently bought a open top silicone with a ¾’ Delrin nozzle. It works great and is much easier to clean up. She actually asks me for enemas now which has never happened in the past!

There are advantages to both that have been previously mentioned; however, I identify with the open top and I have only had one combination bag in my life and I bought it because the store didn't have any hot water bottle. Thank God, I am passed the age that I use a hot water bottle very much.

What pleases one will puke another said my Auntie. But for me the sight of black nozzle in a woman's butt with the red hose leading to a slumped half full open top red bag is tops. Even better if she lets me see her face as she enjoys her enema.

@Ebbie_Anne Open. I have a 4 quart bag and it's very convenient should I need a refill.

Brings back memories of a friend who would bring over a 4 qt red open-top to enema me with.

Open top is my favorite. Easy to clean and they look like an enema bag. Exciting to just look at a full one!

Open top amber latex bag.

Like many people on this site, I have a four quart open bag, a two quart combination and a rectal syringe. The open bag is easy to fill and for those who like two quart enemas, requires less prep. I like the closed bag for high enemas and open bag for large enemas. I do wish I could find a three or four quart closed bag.