Most Painful Implement

A very thorough exposition, @Vasbyt , and one that leaves me relieved i was never subjected to the cane. Indeed, caning seems incredibly rare in the US, except maybe in S&M settings. Guess that's one area our British heritage didn't carry into.

There is two books I have only read one it is called His Deepest Submission the other is her. Were the wife uses a Japanese Tawz that would be probably the most painful

What a read... all these experiences. I'm a spanking newbie, I guess. I've had a bare hand is all. It's going to be a slow progression to whatever is next.

Conventional? Certain canes, or switches for sure. Maybe bath brushes on the thuddy side.

Unconventional? Try an electronic cable like a cell phone charger, Ethernet, or an HDMI.

I've found recently a section of orange outdoor extension cable can create amazing effects and critical changes in attitude. Plus very engaging welts. But does some bruising.

But remember everyone, no matter what you use always remember to follow through. Just don't tap. Strike and pull through. So much more effective.

Rattan cane with out s dout in the hands of man or woman if wielded correctly and well layed out set stripes across ones bottom is very pain full long lasting punishment 8 strokes cane and bum is striped like zebra for best part week

The most painful experiences I had were with the cane, even with the (small) protection of my underpants. A slippering on the bare bottom was painful, but depended on the type of slipper used.

Growing up, the belt was bad and my brother's and I feared it. We also got a spanking stick --- think of a 1" x 4" or so -- if we happened to be downstairs in the garage and needed to be licked.

as an adult, the cane has been the worst for me.

@GraceT Well said. A bare hand spanking on a bare bottom and then not too harsh! I could not under any circumstances give harsh pain to anyone nor do I enjoy harsh pain. I lite OTK on a bare bottom is fun play though.

I hated the belt, it hurt bad and sometimes left welts and always hit places it shouldn't have..

I was caned once...never again...it had me screaming and sincerely begging for Her to stop!!! The pain was way beyond my pain threshold!!!

Prison strap i have one and it scares the hell out of me just to look at it

The cane. It’s the only instrument that guarantees I’ll be crying before the session is over. I think because I can hear it just before impact I tense up amplifying the pain.

This is not based on my feeling a jambok on my derriere, but I have always read in erotica that the South African sjambok is supposed to be the most painful.

I've never experienced a sjambok but most things that have a well deserved reputation for being very painful can also be used in a very sensual way. I've bottomed for cane drumming where I am the drum and that is exciting, with lyrical and kind of mild with a short burst of intensity.

Many years – about 40 years ago – I was in a studio on Neulerchenfelder Street in Vienna because of an enema – this woman specialized in clinical eroticism, but also offered BDSM. In my youthful curiosity, I wanted to know if it was really that bad to be beaten with a cane. She agreed to demonstrate it to me. She tied me, completely naked, facing the wall, to a St. Andrew's cross.

Then there was silence for a few seconds, and suddenly I heard a whistling sound and a loud smack. At the same moment, I felt an incredible pain from my buttocks all the way to the tips of my hair and in the other direction down to my toes. I blacked out for a few seconds from the pain. When the pain subsided and she untied me, I saw a puddle beneath me – I had wet myself from the pain and hadn't even noticed! She gave me a cloth and said in a commanding tone, "Wipe that up, boy."

So, in addition to the pain, there was also this extremely embarrassing and humiliating situation. I will never forget that pain...

I hated the belt, it hurt bad and sometimes left welts and always hit places it shouldn't have..

Maybe that is the reason for using it !!

I would think, the wooden paddle, and of course the cane !!

I think a hair brush is the most painful implement . But anything made of wood does it as well v