Most Painful Implement

I am voting for the cane. Never experienced anything that was as painful.

I am voting for the cane. Never experienced anything that was as painful.

@Mini_Jenni when was you caned was it in school or was it in a a consensual play or punishment

@Medical_man I guess I'd need to be 40-60 years older to get spanked at school. Let's call it consensual play with my bf.

The Oval Oak Paddle is one of the most painful for my naughty bare bottom specially if the spanker has good wrist action when he is making my tush bright red.

I seem to vaguely recall that the hair brush and wooden spoon hurt slightly more than slipper! Though these were all on a fully clothed bottom so it is difficult to make a really accurate judgement! My Father's hand more than any implement; but that would undoubtably be because it was on my bare bottom!

For me the cane is very painful and not very enjoyable, my favorite is a 3/8 inch thick paddle, it gives a even sting and burn is very good especially with a good slow warmup

For me the cane is very painful and not very enjoyable, my favorite is a 3/8 inch thick paddle, it gives a even sting and burn is very good especially with a good slow warmup

Yes, eman445, I can well imagine that a proper cane, one that is flexible and supple and made purposely for punishment must really have a bite to it and hurt like anything! On the bare bottom the pain must be something else! The paddle, which I have never had, (I am British so did not get it at school; and I have never been spanked at all as an adult) must surely be the most effective and efficient spanking implement ever invented; since with every swat the entire bottom feels its burning impact and no area of either butt cheek escapes its attention! Absolute genius!

I seem to vaguely recall that the hair brush and wooden spoon hurt slightly more than slipper! Though these were all on a fully clothed bottom so it is difficult to make a really accurate judgement! My Father's hand more than any implement; but that would undoubtably be because it was on my bare bottom!

Father's hand on bare bottom is the best implement for spanking ! Mine gave very hard and fast smack for a LONG time. I would like to be 10 years old again and revive the spanking of my life, bawling, kicking and crying my eyes out.

Yes, Thalie-little, on a bare bottom even a hand, especially a hard and heavy hand, can hurt like you would not believe!

What do you think is the most painful implement?

My sub's tongue when he says something hurtful without first thinking.

For me, during my childhood, was THE SWITCH! Especialy that kind of switch that can be also named “the rod” as well…

Usually, properly prepared (sometimes by myself after I had also being sent to cut it before) it was not as thin as a regular fresh thinest green switch - it was just a bit thin than the thinnest cane…

Always used on my bare bottom, usually left me with blistered red welts for at least one day. The stinging was incredibile, each welt having his own stinging which was like burning…

In my case, my mother who was my single parent used to choose the switch much more for school affairs (usually for poor grades) or for being lazy.

Growing up and even today, I find being on the receiving end of the hairbrush to be painful. As a kid, it was bare bottom OTK, no warm-ups just a consistent of number of firm whacks on my bottom and upper thighs. My mom and dad did spare for crying. The stinging was intense and it hurt. The old saying, you will sleep on stomach tonight was try after a hairbrush spanking. My parents were big on direct disobedience and those spankings were most severe, but backtalk, not doing chores, poor grades and a bad attitude would get me a good spanking as well.

As an adult, I have had some of the most severe spanking with the hairbrush from both women and men and they definitely knew hard to apply the hairbrush effectively. The last spanking a had in the fall, was severe and I did sleep on my stomach a few nights.

Growing up and even today, I find being on the receiving end of the hairbrush to be painful. As a kid, it was bare bottom OTK, no warm-ups just a consistent of number of firm whacks on my bottom and upper thighs. My mom and dad did spare for crying. The stinging was intense and it hurt. The old saying, you will sleep on stomach tonight was try after a hairbrush spanking. My parents were big on direct disobedience and those spankings were most severe, but backtalk, not doing chores, poor grades and a bad attitude would get me a good spanking as well.

As an adult, I have had some of the most severe spanking with the hairbrush from both women and men and they definitely knew hard to apply the hairbrush effectively. The last spanking a had in the fall, was severe and I did sleep on my stomach a few nights.

Although, spanking wise, I got off very lightly, compared to most other kids,when growing up I do remember that back chat and disobedience were not tolerated by most adults back then!

I would never have dared answer my Father back, had I done so I would have felt the ‘back of his hand’ across my face or around my ear (the famous ‘clip round the ear’!). Even my Mother would take so much backchat, cheek and rudeness before reaching for the hairbrush, slipper, wooden spoon and on one occasion kitchen spatula! Though my 'hidings' were not what I would call proper spankings! (SEE MY PROFILE INTRODUCTION AND BLOG ENTRIES) Most of the teachers at school would not tolerate backchat, disobedience or rudeness either! The number of times I heard the expression; “Don't you ever, ever, EVER talk like that to me again!” The anger and indignation that a youngster had had the nerve to behave that way, towards them so palpable! How different things are today! In the UK anyway!

For me, during my childhood, was THE SWITCH! Especialy that kind of switch that can be also named “the rod” as well…

Usualy, propely prepared (sometimes by myself after I had also being sent to cut it before) it was not at thin as a regular fresh thinest green switch - it was just a bit thin than the thinest cane…

Always used on my bare bottom, usually left me with blistered red welts for at least one day. The stinging was incredibile, each welt having his own stinging who was like burning…

In my case, my mother who was my single parent used to choise the switch much more for school affairs (usually for poor grades) or for being lazy.

The switch sounds truly horrendous! And having to and cut your own must have added to the punishment itself I have seen photos of bottoms and legs that have been switched and the welts always look very vivid and pronounced! Almost too tender and painful to touch! I saw a video of a young lady being given a switching and her tears, sobbing and pleading was really heartfelt and sincere!

For me it has to be the cane. Very much the favourite instrument of correction for the English, and for my generation the first experience probably would have been at school. However I did not develop my fetish for caning until much later in life. The painful results from caning cane be quite mild or result in heavy welts that might last for a week or so.

At the harder end of the scale the cane will be thicker than the usual school version probably more than 10mm in diameter and such an instrument should only be wielded by an expert. Indeed it is unwise to ever submit to any caning from a novice and would be caners should practice on cushions etc. before moving on to real buttocks.

New one to add to the list.. a clear Venetian blind turning stick. Yes the one you use to open and close the slats.

O

M

G

IT HURT LIKE A FUCKING DEMON

We didn't have any Venetian blinds, let alone a stick to turn them.

@Vintage1968 The switch sounds truly horrendous! And having to and cut your own must have added to the punishment .....

For some reason the switch and being switched fascinates me. I never saw a switch being used, though in the early 1950's a friend mentioning how bad it felt and wondered if I was ever switched.

My wife's strap-on.

The worst thing for me is the cane.

Today its the Bath brush and the hair brush. Bath brush is plastic with a long handel. Hair brush is square and flat surface. Both sting like crazy on a naughty bare bottom.

Some people say it is the tawse - but I have no experience of any of these things.

For me the cane is the worst, although someone who can handle a bullwhip well can inflickt a lot of pain as well.

For me personally, the switch. I only got it a handful of (deserved) times, but every time it felt like my butt was being set on fire.

When I was a kid, I was told that if I had been naughty, Santa would fill my stocking with a bag of switches so I could be spanked. Not coal, which is what everyone else was told. Was this just in my family, or were others told the same thing? For what it's worth, not only did I never get switches, but also I can't remember ever having been spanked, though it was threatened many times. Now, of course, I lust for it.

Psychology and the spoken word. It can hurt more than anything physical, and cause trauma that may last a life time.

Belt, it is a burning sting that used to bring tears immediately and a couple of whelts. We also have a heavy leather paddle, made by the London Tanners which used to leave deep tender bruises. I was more fearful of the belt even though it didn't leave as many bruises. I experienced the cane only very lightly and only in play. If it had of been used properly, it would have won hands down.

Without having experienced everything it's impossible to say. Obviously some implements are considered more serious than others so you'd expect them to be more painful.

The cane is the implement I have felt most - that certainly hurts and does leave vivid marks and lasting bruising.

I do have a couple of wooden paddles which I have never fully felt but a bit of experimenting on myself suggests could be pretty unpleasant if administered for real.

In my personal experience the worst was the cane. I didn't get it very often but my Dad was British and he used it for very serious offences - he'd been to boarding school and was caned there. He called it the stick, as in "You'll get the stick for that!" "Do you want a dose of stick, lad?" It was threatened a lot but probably only given five times. The last time I was 16 and he gave me 18 strokes, it was agony. He did it in three sets of six, me bent over his desk. Each set was very hard and stung like hell. In between the sets he lectured me.

I had welts for weeks.

.

The cane, whether Rattan or Delrin, hurts a lot, and the spanker, or caner, doesn't even need to swing the cane very hard to make it hurt a lot. And with a concerted effort, the cane is going to really sting and burn and can leave marks that last much longer than a paddle or hairbrush would produce.

A bare hand or a paddle or a hairbrush or a ping-pong paddle disperses the smack over a wider area than the cane. Yes, those implements can hurt a great deal, but nonetheless, the energy of the smack is dispersed over the butt cheeks.

The cane's thin, narrow surface area concentrates all the force of the blow into a small, targeted region. This creates more intense pressure and a sharper pain than an impact delivered over a wider area by a bare hand or a paddle or a hairbrush or a ping-pong paddle.

With the cane, all of the energy of the smack is concentrated in a thin line of pain that cuts very deep into the cheeks. If done properly, with sufficient force, the stroke produces distinct weals on the buns—long, thin, purple lines of excruciating pain that eventually turn into long, thin, black-and-blue lines of dull, aching pain.

The long length and tremendous flexibility of the cane allows it to be swung with greater speed which maximizes the impact force, and we all remember from our physics classes that force = mass x acceleration, which means there’s a lot of “oomph” when the cane strikes the buttocks. Additionally, the durable nature of the cane, combined with the flexibility, allows the cane to bend during the swing without breaking and then “snap” into the buttocks, delivering a powerful stinging sensation. The full energy of the smack transfers directly into the skin and underlying tissue which can cause blood vessels to rupture, leading to bruising. Strong blows can break the skin which leads to bleeding and deep welts that can take weeks to heal.

The deep tissue trauma leads to lingering soreness, swelling, and a persistent burning sensation that can make it difficult or impossible to sit down for several days. As the injury heals, the area can become even more sensitive to touch, causing pain to be reignited by simple movements or pressure.

To summarize, the cane can really hurt a lot and the hurt can last for quite some time.

.