Experience with different PROFESSIONAL colonic irrigation systems

Different,,, certainly.

However, whether one is "better" than the other is a matter of opinion.

I wish I could find a therapist who does "high" colonics, with a large catheter inserted waaaay up.

The experiential difference between open and closed systems is tremendous.

They have a TOTALLY different feel.

Unfortunately I don’t have a choice. Prefer closed but not available.

There are a number of ladies here in the UK who offer treatment with open and closed systems and encourage their clients to try both.

@Thursdays_child

Might you know if there are any private therapists doing "full colonic washouts" the old fashioned way with a large diameter colon tube, funnel, and pitcher?

These were done, often be retired nurses, who really knew their business. They had a long colon tube, at least 60" long and probably 5/8" to 3/4" outside diameter. They inserted the tube a bit, poured warm water into the funnel, and afer a bit, quickly lowered the funnel into a waste bucket so the client emptied. Th tube was then inserted a bit further and the process repeated. This was continued until mst of the tube was inside the client.

I had the chance to visit such a therapist some years ago, but sadly didn't. She didn't have an available appointment during my visit.

Never come across that sort of thing

I am considering scheduling a session of colon hydrotherapy with a therapist, and I have become aware that there are closed system colonics as well as open system colonics as described at the following link:

https://aqualavage.com/closed-system-vs-open-system-colonics/

What experiences have you had with theses types of colon hydrotherapy? Which one do you recommend?

If you have the choice, go for a closed system. Much more relaxing. I've had both - and would always choose a closed systeme if available. You will always have a therapist (if there is such a thing) with you with a closed system - not always with an open system. It's nice to just lay there and let the machine do the work.

I too recommend a closed system.

An open system colonic is, in reality, merely an alternative method for taking a high volume enema. I find the closed system to be much better, as I can just lay there and let the therapist and machine do all the work.

I’ve done both and prefer the Closed System over the Open.

The only reason open system colonics have grown in number while the closed system facilities have declined in number is because the "therapist", and I use that term loosely, can service several people at one time in contrast to the closed system where the therapist must be present with the client to operate the machine.

Be prepared to spend somewhat more for a closed system colonic than an open system colonic---the price difference is well worth it.

The main reason I tried the Open System was the lady I saw in my area of North Carolina, moved to SeaTac, Washington. This was circa 2010, an I tried her recommended alternatives an all used the Open System. I tried it twice, didn’t care for it, and quite going. Even though the cost was less, it wasn’t enough to keep me going back to something I didn’t prefer.

A closed system colonic is the best way to go in my opinion. It seems that most are in agreement here. I've had both closed and open, and find that the interaction with the therapist, using the closed system, is well worth a few extra bucks.

I used colon hydrotherapy to aid in preparation for my last colonoscopy, and will again in the near future. This will be in addition to the nasty "top down" effort in compliance with instructions.

My last therapist, now retired, let me know that all of her clients were "ass-holes". She was right on the money with her wit and sense of humor. I would have been a more frequent client if she were still working. I enjoyed many discussions about regular colon cleansing and enema use. She was certainly a proponent and a number of local celebrities used her services.

The one thing that was a negative, was that she didn't provide a full blown massage ( abdomen only). Few things could beat an "Enemassage" in my book. Combining the two would be heavenly.

@SwitchableSusie

I somewhat disagree with your reasoning about the growing popularity of open systems, rather than closed.

While some therapists can support two clients at once with an open system, two is about the practical limit. On the open system, there is a lot more cleanup, disinfecting, and other messy tasks after each client. This takes time. Not to mention poo remaining in the toilet slot.

With a closed system, the disposable speculum and hoses are thrown away, wrapped in the Chux pad, the machine put into cleaning mode, and it next client time.

IMO, the choice really depends more on the experience desired by the client. A closed system session is far more subbie than an open system session, because another person, the therapist, utterly controls your bowel. When the speculum is in, there is NOTHING you can do to resist the water inflow or outflow. Not even Superman can clench their anal muscles to make any difference. The therapist is in full and complete control of your bowel and sees everything that comes out.

On an open system, the client is in full control of water retention and release. The session is also completely private.

@Sean said

. . . . . IMO, the choice really depends more on the experience desired by the client. A closed system session is far more subbie than an open system session, because another person, the therapist, utterly controls your bowel. When the speculum is in, there is NOTHING you can do to resist the water inflow or outflow. Not even Superman can clench their anal muscles to make any difference. The therapist is in full and complete control of your bowel and sees everything that comes out.

On an open system, the client is in full control of water retention and release. The session is also completely private.

That is absolutely NOT the case when I go for a colonic. I go because I like being pampered and they do it MY way.

I don't require privacy during my colonics, so I don't care that there is someone else in the room. Everyone's shit looks about the same coming out during a colonic.

My therapist inserts the speculum while I am on my side, and needing to be on your left side for the insertions is a MYTH. Sometimes I just lie on my back and pull my legs up into a diaper position for the speculum insertion because that way I don't have to be careful not to displace the speculum when I turn from my side onto my back. After lying back for a minute, she starts the water flow when I say I am ready. I am in complete control of the water flow IN and OUT. I say when to start the water in, when to stop the flow MOMENTARILY (not release it) so I can massage it around and to release it when I say to release it. I control the temperature, the flow rate and pressure by telling them exactly what I want. I often schedule myself for 90 to 120 minutes on the machine. Yes, I pay extra for the added or double time. My therapists know I enjoy the colonics, and it is all done very professionally.

If you know your body, this works MUCH better than having someone else decide when to fill and empty your colon. NONE of the therapists I ever had in my 130-140 or so colonics over the last 30 years knew anything of stopping and holding the in-flow during "the fill" and just holding the water for a minute or two while the water circulates around the colon until I told them to do that, but doing that helps tremendously to get more water in and a better cleanse. The colonic schools could take a lesson from that.

Note: What I called the "better cleanse" is getting a very clear return and is purely for fun and the sensations. I never expect any health benefits from colonics or enemas. They are all for the sensations and pleasure of being pampered.

@switchablesusie - Note: What I called the "better cleanse" is getting a very clear return and is purely for fun and the sensations. I never expect any health benefits from colonics or enemas. They are all for the sensations and pleasure of being pampered.

ABSOLUTELY!!! I never bought off on the "colon hydrotherapy" myth that it clears "plaque" that has caked on my colon lining. If I were merely interested in getting a completely clean colon and a clear return, I could to a colonoscopy prep. Colonics are all about relaxation and the attention from the "therapist".

Susie is so right! (As usual!) I began satisfying my somewhat kinky interest in colonics with a "Libbie" machine and really found it somewhat strange and not particularly satisfying emotionally or physically. Then a clinic started (wonderfully called "Bottoms Up") that had closed systems, various bells and whistles including ozone and implants, and really interesting and caring staff. So I also make my visits a "bliss out" event which does me good, possibly unrelated to any medical effect of several gallons of warm filtered water flowing in and out. But perhaps not totally unrelated...

Will agree, closed much better. Had a GREAT therapist that really went all out. Havent found any one like her since. She would start me out w/ a 2qt soapy enema, using a enema can. She would have me expell, then she would give me another 2 qt soapy using a colon tube. She would be able to get the tube very high up. She would give me the full 2 qts. and then lead me to the colonic table , while i held the enema.she would insert the specullum, and quickly withdraw the plunger, and attach the waste tube. There was always some leakage , but she was ready for it. These were the best colnics i have ever had. She was a true pro, and ingnored my constant erctions. BTW, i was in a knee chect position during the enemas

Not really sure what is closed or open, ive had numerous colonics over the years, mostly from what looked a bit like a glass fish tank full of water, temp controlled, had a large speculum pushed into me by the therapist, who proceeded to fill me, asking when id had enough, then draining me , over and over, and most of the time was also massaging my belly. One other type, which i shant bother with again, was shown where to impale myself on a pipe sticking out of a drain/shield, and left to my own devices, woman turned it on and left the room, no help or advice or massage......nothing.

Former is "closed", sounds like a Woods Gravity system, while the latter is "open". Both have their merits, but as you allude it is principally down to the therapist. I have had "open" colonics where the therapist has remained with me, chatted, massaged my tummy and her assistant has popped in with cups of herbal tea. I have also been for "closed" colonics where the environment and the attitude of the therapist have made me feel "never again". My favourite lady "the twinkly granny" who sadly isn't working at present due to COVID-19 restrictions, uses a Toxygen colonic machine, a Silicon Nozzles speculum enhancement nozzle, burns incense and candles and provides a truly amazing experience. We discuss everything under the sun and I take her flowers and wine. Hugs before and after and even, once, a run out in my old MG roadster. Uuumm.

I've had colonics administered to me for many, many years - in cities all over the country, from Los Angeles to New York - and using a wide variety of systems. For a thorough cleansing, I'm absolutely convinced that a closed system is the most effective. Unattended open systems were developed as much to enable the therapist to manage more than one client at a time as for any other reason. However, some of the best and most effective sessions I've ever had were with a therapist who used an open system but remained in the room for much of the session administering abdominal massage manually and with a large body massager. Nothing sexual involved, just massage to facilitate opening up and releasing. Felt wonderfully cleansed afterward.

I have never had a colonic and have for so long wished to experience one. Maybe both the open and the closed so I could compare which I would enjoy. Can't say as never experienced. I have no idea how to go about getting a colonic of any kind. Does someone know of a place in or near Connecticut where I could go and receive my first? Please message me if you do. I would be very grateful to you.

Does someone know of a place in or near Connecticut where I could go and receive my first?

@FunGuy Google is your friend. Try "Connecticut Colon Hydrotherapy" or "Connecticut Colonics". You could even specify a city.

@FunGuy

To find a reliable colon hydrotherapist, go to I-ACT.org and click on the tab "Find a Therapist" and then enter your state or city.

These folks take colonics seriously. They are NOT sex workers, but do give safe colonics, using FDA approved equipment.Have a session with any of their members an you'll poo a lot.

I have taken enemas and colonics most of my life. My most reliable therapist is ME! That's because about ten years ago I purchased a used Toxigen B and installed it in my home. It gets used about once a week. I have a real professional practitioner that I visit about every six weeks who offers NO "Extra Services" and gives great Colon Hydrotherapies. I recommend finding such a professional through IACT or personal recommendation.

A professional Colon Hydrotherapy leaves you feeling wonderful but an enema a day keeps the doctor away!