Which is a better enema-the Fleet or the Bag?

The red bag

Always liked using fleets as i like to fill a diaper, and the small liquid amount was containable in the diaper, and they really emptied me out....BUT.........after doing this many times, i finally connected fleet enemas to me feeling awfull for the rest of the day, whereas a bag enema didnt, so forget fleets, warm soapy water any day ! Must be some of the chemicals in them my body disliked i guess.

An Ivory enema is heaven. Especially if it's in an open top bag with suds dripping down the side.

Bag for sure I have had fleets too quick same result just not as fun.

I prefer a bag. fleet are too harsh and bring discomfort

Hands down a bag enema! If for no other reason than the Fleets are painful and uncomfortable. Just a bad of warm water and some soap or baking soda and salt and you're set.

I like bag enemas, and sometimes a bulb for a partner over my knee. The only Fleet enemas I've ever enjoyed giving were the mineral oil ones, very messy but great for play. The Regular Fleets are too harsh.

People, people, people. This question "Enema Bag" or "Fleet Enema" is like debating is the glass 1/2 full or 1/2 empty.

There are so many variables that need to be taken into consideration.

Is the person needing the enema because they are constipated, are they impacted, are they having surgery, is the surgery GI involving the rectum or intestines, is the patient pregnant or giving birth, what is the age of the person, have they ever had enemas before and do they like things anal and like feeling things being inserted into the rectum.

My point is if you are a doctor and going to examine a patient you surely are going to ask questions first so you have an idea of what may needs to be looked at more than something else.

I will give 2 examples of what I am saying

1. When working on the floors in the hospital I had a patient who told doctor she was a little sluggish and bowels were not doing what she wanted them to do. Doc said no problem I will order you some fleet enemas. So he ordered fleet enema each morning for two days. So I to went to patients room, told her doc ordered fleet enema for you. She was about 40 years old, 6' tall, 220 lbs. So I had her turn on her side, lift her right leg up to her chest, added some lube to her anus and told her what I was doing and I inserted the enema nozzle as deep as I could and gave it a big squeeze and she says let me know when you do it, I said it is all done. The point is for this lady a fleet did nothing. The next day she received 2 full bag enemas.

2. I had a patient having surgery and doc wrote order, TWE, tap water enema, till clear. Ok, got the enema bag, went to the patients room, told him what I needed to do. Wife was sitting in chair in the corner knitting. He started to complain and before I could say anything wife says "Henry shut up and take your enemas" and he did. It took 7 enemas till he was clear and his wife did not miss a stitch in like 2+ hours. Thank God he was able to walk to the bathroom each time.

So you have to look at everything before you take or give enemas.

That is why shoes come in so many different sizes. My X's mother wore 9EEE, no joke.

I have been getting the FLEET products since about being a 1 year old baby girl.I have always had a constipation problem since about my first year.My mommy got suggestion from my pediatrician and started first with just suppositories.My mommy explained my progression from suppositories to enema's when I was old enough to understand.She told me if I didn't have a messy diaper within 3 days,and I was getting very fussy,at my diaper change she would give me 1 suppository,and then rediaper me.She explained that was the same process she followed until I was about 3 years old.She was never really a fan of the suppositories,because of the unpredicability of the timing of action.She told me they did work on me,and was happy about that.She then moved to the child Fleet enema's and much preferred them,because she could count on the enema working within 10-20 minutes.Once again she gave me the enema's at my diaper changes,on the same rountine as the suppositories.When I got older,she she kept a good supply of both the FLEET suppositories and the FLEET child enema's on hand for me.Again if no BM in 3 days,then it was an enema and then Had to sit on my potty training seat so mommy could check the results.That was to continue until I was about 9 years old.Mommy when I was 9 did try to use a bag enema on me,but I didn't really like the very full feeling I got and continued to complain while getting an enema via bag.Mommy then went back to the Fleet products,and I was more comfrtable using those,after sooo many years of needing them.They are always MY preference for cleaning this girl out.

An Ivory enema is heaven. Especially if it's in an open top bag with suds dripping down the side.

Gotta agree - as my moniker photos shows, it's what I love too! Also, I like the long expulsion time provided by 2 - 3 qts of very warm soapy water. Don't like the little squirt results from a fleet.

I prefer the bag but I also love bulbs

The "BAG" without a doubt! Hands Down!

It really depends on my mood. Often it's the bag with approx 1,5litres. But sometimes I'm keen into something fast like Cleen-Enema or Laxavit.

It depends on the situation . For a quick cleaning I use a fleet . For a relaxed and fun time I love the bag

They both have their best use.

Generally the bag will win every time but there ARE situations when you want to use a Fleet.

The good old fashioned bag with soapy water and the larger nozzle.

Sure, they both serve a purpose. As well stated below. They can also be used in a single session. Using a Fleet to clear the way so your bag's lovely nozzle doesn't get clogged. Thus not satisfactorily delivering the goods so to speak.

I prefer the bag enema. I have used Fleet's but do not find the insertion or the expulsion satisfying. A bag enema is one that you can enjoy. You can savor the nozzle insertion and the slow expansion of your insides as the water fills you.

Has anyone tried a Fleet glycerin enema. i saw it advertised on TV, so I bought 2 with a coupon 😃 . Me and/or my wife are yet to try them...

A 2 qt red bag filled with hot soapy water then a rinse enema with warm water i keep filling the bag until the water comes out clear then i know i am cleaned out

It is an individual opinion. I without a second's hesitation or thought, greatly prefer a bag enema or a aeries of bulb fillings laying over my husband's lap.

It is an individual opinion. I without a second's hesitation or thought, greatly prefer a bag enema or a aeries of bulb fillings ...

My exact feeling, but here's something funny; when it comes to what videos I like to watch, I find seeing a woman given Fleets to be the most exciting, especially in a medical setting, and if she's given two Fleet in a row, even better. Seeing all the squeezing of the Fleet to get ever drop in, is exciting.

I am a bag guy all the way... nozzles change, but the bags remain. This is where I got mine.

https://www.amazon.com/Non-Toxic-Silicone-Cleanse-Phthalates-Mikacare/dp/B074BQFPXG/ref=sr_1_4_sspa?dchild=1&keywords=enema+bag&qid=1611071593&sr=8-4-spons&psc=1&spLa=ZW5jcnlwdGVkUXVhbGlmaWVyPUFUVzQxOEtWUFNQTVEmZW5jcnlwdGVkSWQ9QTAwNjI1MjIyNFgxN085RFo0UDExJmVuY3J5cHRlZEFkSWQ9QTA3NzE1MTQzSjZQWkw1RUJEUEZEJndpZGdldE5hbWU9c3BfYXRmJmFjdGlvbj1jbGlja1JlZGlyZWN0JmRvTm90TG9nQ2xpY2s9dHJ1ZQ==

I have been playing with this also. Whole different feeling and actually harder for me to take. 600ml vs 2000ml seems like it would be easier... but no.

https://www.amazon.com/Vaginal-Douche-Cleaner-Cleaning-Cleansing/dp/B07W82NB96/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&keywords=enema+pump&qid=1611071739&sr=8-2

Enemas forever!

Definately an enema administered from a classic red 2 quart enema bag with a black enema nozzle on the business end is what I enjoy.

The bag 100%. Nothing takes the place of you being told that you are "getting an enema" or You are going to have your ass washed out". Then you sit there anticipating when this will take place and what time. When the time comes, you are prepared by baring your ass as the bag is removed from it's storage area, assembled in front of you then as you lay there, you hear the water running and the other preparations. Then she walks out and enters the room you are in, carrying a bulging, full enema bag with it's hose and clamp then the nozzle of her choice. Then she hangs up the bag and lubes the nozzle and your opening. Then she slides the nozzle into you then the sound of the "click" of the clamp then the sound of the warm soapy water flowing. Finally the feeling of the warm soapy water filling you, usually two quarts or more of fluid. You do NOT get that from a Fleet!!!!

Like the majority of others chiming in --- bag 100% of the time, every time, any time.

When I was a young boy I had issues pooping. I held back when I felt the urge to go. This led to me getting backed up. It also caused me to mess my pants. My parents took me to see a doctor. He first figured out I was really backed up by putting his finger in my bum. Then the doctors tried a suppository which did not work. All it did was cause my butt to burn and sting. Then he tried a fleet enema. The fleet only caused me to release a small amount of poopy liquid. Then he tried a bag enema. That worked but he needed to really fill me up. That did the trick and that caused my booty to explode with massive poop explosions. I remember crying and pooping for over an hour.

As I soon realized as well there is nothing in the world that gives you the feeling a bag enema does. Nothing comes close to it. Nothing.

The bag hands down!!

Absolutely the bag. Its all about feeling full, the hold, and the release. I love the volume and feeling it enter me. Can't live without it.

The bag all the way. The Fleet will help you have a BM. The bag will clean the playground so the games can begin.