Which is a better enema-the Fleet or the Bag?

There's no doubt a Fleet will do the trick. But to get that really satisfying feeling of being completely cleaned out there is no substitute for the enema bag. Besides the bag use can be prolonged and with it the enjoyment. When thinking of enemas, I think soap and water not chemicals.

The bag only for me unless all I need is a quick spritz in which case, a couple of flushes with a large enema bulb that I have in the tool box.

While we much prefer the bag,if the time is not availoble and we want some anal training or play, Fleets works well.

I once had to use a Fleet enema before a medical examination but was not turned on at all by this and much prefer the taking the traditional red rubber bag enemas!

Because the Fleet is full of chemicals, it forces you to expel fairly quickly and violently; the chemicals could be bad for all of the microorganisms that live inside of you. If taken at wide intervals, it might not cause a problem, but I prefer to use plain water, four quarts for me, maybe less for you, which can be a long and enjoyable time filling and less of the immediate need for expulsion. In short, a bag full of plain water is a more enjoyable experience, and I recommend it.

My first enema was a Fleet that my girlfriend and I took out of curiosity. It was quite effective. Over the next few years I occasionally used Fleet type enemas when I felt I needed one. I did not particularly like or dislike them, they were just a means of making me shit when I needed to.

Once my cousin showed me what an enema with the bag is like, I realized there can be a lot more to an enema than just making you shit. It is a whole process and a whole lot of interesting feelings throughout the body and mind.

If you just need to shit, take a Fleet. They are pretty good at that. If you want an experience, take the time to use the bag. There is no comparison as far as I am concerned.

Hands down, the bag over the fleet type enema. I like the full feeling that you don't get with the chemical squirt. I also want an enema to last longer than the quick little bottle does.

Bill

Bulb or bag are preferred rather than fleet

Hang a bag........get a woody!!!

The bag for sure, but I had a guy give me eight of of those large bottle fleets then make me hold it while he spanked me for almost and hour. I thought I would die of cramps, that lasted way past when he let me expel.

The 8 oz. in a Fleet enema just cannot compare to a 2 quart bag enema. Besides who wants all those chemicals that the Feet has in it. Nothing works better than 2-3 quarts of nice warm soapy water released high up into the rectum with one of those long fat (10 inch) silicone nozzles.

Warning on Fleet Enemas has been issued by the FDA. Follow the recommendations on the box. No more than one unit a day is safe. The guy that posted he held eight is lucky to be alive.

The best enema I have found is taking in two quarts (1.9L) of soap suds solution with an 8 oz. (250ml) Adult Rectal Bulb Syringe. This is how mother did it 60 years ago and still the best.

In my opinion, the bag is much better. I like to refer to Fleets as liquid cramps in a bottle. But I do realize that there are those that enjoy the cramping. I am not one of those.

No Fleets for me. They irritate a lot more than a couple of 2 quart enemas.

The problem with Fleet enemas is you are injecting chemicals into your body which are against your mucosa and not at all good for you. If you really like the bulb, then get an empty one and fill it with whatever you prefer to play with. Stay away from Fleets.

And, they cost a lot more than plain tap water.

hankb

Give me the bag any day. doing the prep and watching the bag empty is part of the fun that you don't get with a fleet, and the bag takes longer.MUCH MORE FUN !!!!

I'm a huge fan of Fleet enemas and I think they have their advantages for certain situations. For some purposes, I prefer them to the bag. I think they are a great way to get a quick easy clean out for other anal play. A Fleet enema allows me to be through in 15 to 20 mn feeling clean, comfortable and confident. The main draw back being they contain a strong laxative which has a residual effect. Most of the time for me, this clears out after about an hour. I've also found that a bulb enema of plain tap water will speed this process up.

If your main focus is the enema itself or you want a deep cleaning or don't like the chemicals in the Fleet enema, then the bag is the only way to go. The bag is very versatile and would be my choice if I had to take one or the other. So while there advantages to the Fleet enema, a bag is the better choice. Not to sound like an advertisement for Fleet, because I think they charge a lot of money for what they are selling, but I've used several of their products and have always been very satisfied.

A bag with a long latex hose, no tip and then start with about 3 inches let the soapy (ivory) start to run and keep pushing the hose up till I get about 12". Then lay there and enjoy!! In the second round you will be able to insert the hose further but if you feel it get to high and uncomfortable stop pull back let it flow. I have an open top silicone 2 qt bag I fill twice for a complete fill lay there enjoy till you have to evacuate. It is great - for me!!

I prefer the bag, mostly due to the volume and thrill of the build up in peristalsis and sexual tension. But from time to time I like to use the Fleet bisacodyl enemas either by itself for the intense peristalsis and quickness of action on its own or chased with a 3 or 4 L saline enema. I avoid the phosphate Fleet enemas mainly due to the high sodium content that due to my health is not good for me.

I personally don't like the fleets. Wether for constipation or pleasure I prefer 2 to 4 quarts ini the red bag. Sometimes I add about 8 oz. mineral oil before taking the bag. The oil gives me a great clean out and expulsion

IMO it is all about the process and the excitement of getting out the enema bag, doing the preparation, and taking it is beyond description. A fleet is too small, too quick and of the two that I had was not satisfied with the results and took a regular bag enema after. There are times when convenience is not worth the cost.

I would say avoid Fleets if you plan on anal play afterwards. Fleets can be quite hard on the intestinal lining. Anyway I much prefer getting rid of a nice load of water than a paltry poo.

An RN gave me a Fleets to try many years ago. No thanks! Bag every time. If I need to do something quick I'll use a Higginson's with a colon tube but that really defeats the object of the exercise which is to relax. As my beloved therapist keeps on saying "take your time"!

I am not for Fleet enema, all chemicals, or empty Fleet can be used for its own liquid. Even better is Multi-Gyn Amazon, for vaginal douching but also very well suited for enema. A.

Both of them can be usefull - If I need an enema and have that much time a Fleet can be very good.

Bag is much better.

I would rather have a bag and a douche nozzle slow and exciting.

Bag all day

For this GIRL,I grew up getting FLEET products,and have also had a couple bags.I do not like the VERY full feeling I get from the BAG ones giving to me by my mommy or older sister.I do enjoy the whole process of getting Fleet ones,much more enjoyable for me and my giver!!