Differences between enemas that are HARD to hold, EASY to hold and PAINFUL?

There are threads on uncomfortable and hard to hold enemas.

That brings us to the question:

Is there a difference between enemas that are

HARD to hold, EASY to hold and PAINFUL?

Earlier this week I took a 1 quart water enema following immediately with a 20 ml shot of glycerin up my rectum. No cramps or pain was produced, but the hold time was less than 5 minutes.

Cramps and urgency are usually called out separately, so I think that there would be. I think that volume is a factor here, a smaller volume of a stronger solution would be more likely to be hard to hold, whereas a larger volume would be more likely to have painful cramps.

I have had painful cramps sometimes, but don't consider them intolerable. The part that I don't like is when you get nausea.

I'd submit that there can be a significant difference in my experience. There have been times when a simple TWE was very hard to hold and a mad dash to the toilet was necessary. It wasn't necessarily painful, it's just that the urgency was so substantial, that immediate release was required. This has happened with a SSE, Coffee, as well as an M&M enema.

I've had very few enemas that I would characterize as painful. On a couple of occasions, a painful cramp may have developed that didn't necessitate immediate expulsion. I do try to avoid painful enemas as I believe they could be indicative of more serious underlying issues.

I think there is a significant difference between the discomfort of a strong, crampy enema and pain. I have had many uncomfortable enemas with strong cramps and the urgency to expel it now, but I do not remember any that I would classify as painful.

I do have to qualify my opinion by saying I have never had to hold a very strong enema such as M&M while prevented from expelling with something like a double balloon nozzle. That might be painful.

I've had a few that cross the line over into pain. Those are the ones where you're doubled over on the toilet with your brain in neutral just wanting it to be over.

Those are rare.

SSE4Fun is right about your colon playing a part. Sometimes it's more likely to overreact.

I find M & M enemas very hard to hold, but not necessarily painful. I suppose if I was forced to hold it with a large butt plug or balloon nozzle, it might become painful after a bit, but I've never had the latter occur. I'm into pleasure, not pain.

I frequently use a double balloon nozzle...the effect is that an enema user that has some experience quickly knows to relax and not clutch her anus...this seems to relax her and make taking the enema much easier....if it is NOT to punish her, I use the valve control with the little swirling red ball inside and give her the enema very slowly....the only real pain ever reported is when she has to hold for several minutes and is sealed up tight....usually from a punishment enema.....slow filling seems to alleviate the cramping up until above three quarts...after that it just depends on how she's doing that day...and how tense she is...ie....has she been docile...or maybe she's been spanked first

There is.

Hard to hold ones with lots of cramping are what happen to me when I use too much soap. I enjoy these ones as it take a bit of work to get through the cramping to where it is just discomfort. Then I can SLOWLY top it up until I have a full colon that is distended and uncomfortable

One of the first times I used soap, I used too much and the cramping was quite painful and I toughed it out while adding more water to dilute the contents of my colon

There is definitely a difference between an enema that is hard to hold and one that is painful.

For example, solutions that have a lot of glycerine can be hard to hold because they cause a lot of churning in the intestines but they aren't painful.

Solutions with pepper sauce or brewed pepper infusions or large volume milk and molasses enemas can cause pain and nausea, mint oils and soaps like green soap just plain burn and cause pain even with small volumes even though they aren't hard to hold because they don't cause contractions that make you expel it, they just simply hurt until you have a thorough rinse.

There are ones that are both hard to hold and painful. Ones where you get strong cramps that hurt as well as make you wonder if you will safely make it to the toilet.

There is for sure a difference between pain and hard to hold.pain is your body,s way of saying stop before you do damage hard to hold just means a little discomfort just my 2 cents

At nominal volumes, there can be a difference depending upon the enema solution. Obviously, someone who tries to take on a 5 gallon enema is going to find it both hard to hold and painful.

For me, the confluence of hard to hold and painful is a very soapy and very high, variable concentration glycerin enema. That is a 15%, 4-liter soapy enema. But it's put together in a particular way. It's 600 ml of glycerin added to bag and then allowed to fill the tube (and in the case where I'm using my tube with the Higginson pump, filling the pump as well). This is followed with the addition of 3.4 liters of warm water that has a full 90 gram bar of Ivory soap (shaved/grated) dissolved into it. I carefully pour the soapy water into the bag. Although there is some degree of mixing between the glycerin in the bag and the soapy water, there is still a degree of stratification in the bag (it is visible in my clear bag) and the first 150 ml out the tube IS pure glycerin.

After inserting and inflating the double balloon nozzle, when I open the flow control valve, the flow through the nozzle is quite slow (glycerin is pretty viscous) and probably coats the upper rectum/lower sigmoid. As the first 200-250 ml flow in, the concentration of glycerin begins to drop from 100%, but I have no easy way to determine what the concentration is. By the time the first liter is in, the visible stratification between the glycerin layer and soapy solution layer is gone. Basically, from there to the final amount I let flow in, any mixing is occurring in my colon.

At these strengths, the ability to hold it any length of time is challenging and it takes a fairly concentrated effort on my part to hold it beyond 10 minutes. But it can also be painful because the colon seems sensitized by the high glycerin concentration while the strength of the soap tends to feel more like a burn. I've done each of these enemas individually (glycerin only and soap only) and I respond differently to the individual component solution compared to the combined.

The "cramps" can be painful because rather than just strong muscle contractions, they act more like a muscle cramps.

The glycerin is a very sensitive tingle at these levels.

The soap is more of a burning sensation.

It is an interesting combination of pain and pleasure. And only once did I think I shouldn't have done this type of enema.

I've found lots of recipes out there that cause horrible cramps but are hard to hold. I tried glycerin suppositories for the first time last night. I used two the first time. It hurt so badly but was easy to hold due to the fact it wasn't a real "enema".

I do Enemas almost every day. I've always had a hard time going to the toliet.

I was thinking about using 3 tonight or injecting them with something to make the pain worse. Any suggestions on how i could mod them or does anyone have any enema recipes that would do my job.

I usually take and hold 2 liters of water with a few tablespoons of Epson salts mixed in.

I was thinking about using 3 tonight or injecting them with something to make the pain worse. Any suggestions on how i could mod them or does anyone have any enema recipes that would do my job.

Try this:

https://www.zity.biz/index.php?mx=forum;ox=display;topic=102932

I promise you WILL be sorry!

Muwahahahahaha!

@SwitchableSusie - Awww, c'mon Susie: she just wants a little pain with her action...your very rough ride is a killer!

Ha! Don't know if I'm ready that monster. I plan on using some glycerin and ivory soap. We'll see how that works.

I have done it about 15 times in my life and I'm still alive!

Add an ounce of pure vegetable glycerin to a half liter or liter soapy enema and hold it until you have to go really bad. Or a quicky is to inject half an ounce to an ounce of the glycerin and retain it for twenty minutes or more. The first four to five will be a little hard, then the urge goes away only to return after fifteen minutes and soon after that, you have to go. It's a small enema that always works.

Make a mix of warm water and glycerine (try a health food store, in the health and beauty section you can get a 16oz bottle for nearly the same as a tiny 4oz at the pharmacy) inject 20-30ccs with a medicine syringe (found in the baby care section) then get on the floor or bed, head down, bottom up and wait. I like a mix of no more than 50/50, more water for a more gentle, easier to hold effect, more glycerine if you want to pant and sweat a bit! Follow up with a couple of clear water rinses, or a soapy bag followed by rinse(s) to flush out the remaining glycerine.