Which is more babyish?

Pacifier. It just seems like its only there when your a baby

Pacifier, no question 😃

I think a pacifer during the day is more babyish... but at night, i falls out whereas my thumb doesn't, so I guess at night, thumb sucking is more babyish...

I feel a pacifier is more babyish, but I've also been a thumb/finger sucker (entirely apart from my AB/DL side) basically since puberty hit. The pacifier is actually more suited to me not only because it's more babyish, but because I have injured myself sucking my thumb and fingers. There isn't that risk with the paci.

I think a pacifier and thumb sucking are babyish i like to do both, i carry a paci with me but i like to suck my thumb. Sometimes i have forgot where i am and started sucking my thumb and my aunt has pointed out where i was and i went bright red and stopped.

MY BINKIE makes me feel more babyish! But I do suck my thumb as well!

I also suck my pacifier, or thumb when being spanked by my wife, it helps to keep me quiet & in my " sub space"! ( Most times she will stop me from doing this).

EVERRYBODY (mostly) as at least one thumb, and can suck on it without having anyone put it in your mouth, However, a binky needs forethought, as it has to be specifically purchased, either by the ABy or by a parent figure. Mommy isn't likely to put your thumb into your mouth, but certainly can demand you suck on your binky.

The idea that a binky requires planning makes It much more babyish than a very common thumb. Either is babyish, but the binky is much more babyish! Besides, thumbs on adults are never considered anything other than normal, but binkys are ALWAYS considered as an infant/toddler accessory, either when used by a young child or by an adult.

My best to all,

Binkey

I would say a dummy (pacifier) is more babyish than thumb sucking plus its more hygienic than sucking on your thumb

I think seeing a woman thats sucking her thumb is much sexier then seeing her sucking on a pacifier.

I feel a pacifier lets everyone know your a baby for sure and if they see the diapers and plastic pants they will definitly know. I do love my pacifiers, i wear them on my babybibs

BIG question! I prefer a pacifier and i know my dentist would rather see me suck on an ortho one. But sometimes when im watching TV my thumb will end up in my mouth not thinking. Yes a thumb is more baby but as we all know its not good to do bad teeth.

Lifelong thumb sucker here. Never really used a pacifier.

I soooo prefer my pacifiers over my thumb. I do think the pacifiers are much more babyish over my thumb & I still nurse my pacifier every night to fall asleep. Whenever cranky or fussing my mommy always makes sure I have a pacifier in my mouth. Thank you mommy !!!

I think a pacifier is more babyish because you can pick what color is it and what designs are on it. I also think it is really babyish to have your pacifier hanging on your shirt waiting to be used.

I think that pacifiers are more babyish because it reminds the person of the sucking mechanism when he/she was a baby.

There is no way a girl sucking her thumb isnt looking adorable

Dummies are more babyish i have seen loads with dummies which i find is fine it's like trying to give up your comfort blanket and it failing you just need that sense of comfort with you at all times

I would have to say a pacifier is more babyish to me. To see someone sucking on a pacifier and going in and out of the mouth as they suck very babyish.

I think sucking a dummy/pacifier is more babyish than thumb sucking as your mummy can tell you to suck your dummy and it enforces who is in charge

Definitely a Binki. When my wife sticks a binki in my mouth, I feel like a baby more so than her telling me to suck my thumb when she says

" Just stop talking" or when she is punishing me.

Sucking an big adult pacifier is more childish in my eyes.

Last night, while sound asleep, my wife yanked my pacifier out of my mouth, then hid it or threw it out! Now this morning I will have to beg her for it! I will probably just need to buy a new one! WAAAAA, WAAAAA!

My Pacifier! ( Every time I try to take it out of my mouth I find myself sucking harder to keep it in place!!!!)

My mommy/friend told me I would use a pacifier vs sucking my thumb. She said it is more babyish if I have a pacifier in my mouth.

I feel that a pacifier is way more babyish as when someone sees you sucking on one they kinds get the feeling you belong in diapers

Definitely a pacifier. I sucked my thumb to about 6 or 7... it definitely contributed to my over-bite. The solution was to give me a pacifier again. I think my parents thought it would cure me of the habit and I'd be embarrassed.

Neither of those ended up happening. I've been using one off and on since (I'm late 30's now) and enjoy the feeling of it. I'm also AB/DL and a furry/babyfur.

Definitely a paci...cuddle a stuffie pop it in bam instant little space

A thumb is way more babyish, I dont consider pacifiers infintile as people need them for medical reasons too for example to help prevention of blocking of airways due to sleep achninia and also to prevent people from grinding their teeth unknowingly while asleap.

I actually find pacifiers soothing and they help to drastically reduce my snoring I use a baby pacifier from boots innthe UK for 6-9 mouth Old's as it fits my mouth perfectly and glows in the dark as well.

My choice is either a NUC pacifier or a Philips one as they bouth are good at what there meant for.

Yours sincerely

Chinababy888.

Talking from experience I still suck my thumb to this day so I will say pacifier aha