You'll do fine with two or three fingers or a prostate toy like the Pure NJoy Wand
Susie, you missed part of my prostate post, but great suggestion! I've been using the njoy PureWand after trying some less firm toys. My PW is perfect firmness (stainless) and length, also with a nice curve to help my aging wrist work better, for prostate massage. It's posted at the online store where I bought it as 1" and 1.5" balls at the two ends. Either is fine but I find I get a smoother more consistent massage if I use the 1.5" ball. I love it and it's great for nonprostate anal play also.
I have no affiliation, but I bought it on sale last year at
http://www.betweenthesatinsheets.com/Njoy-Pure-Wand_p_21.html,
where it seems to be perpetually on sale at $67.25 on a list price of $110. Its the same sale price today. It's definitely a Cadillac/Lexus/Acura sort of toy, but it was the best one I ever tried for my prostate. I also own their PurePlug butt plug, large size (S/M//L), and will probably wind up buying the PurePlug 2.0 which is an XL size at a 2" diameter. The S, M, L are 1", 1.25" and 1.5" max diameter. I'll use the 2.0 gradually as I work on moving up from 1.5--->2" plugs, which I'm looking forward to starting. I had very good experience with them, as I had never heard of them before buying these toys. The CEO sent me very helpful, polite emails about the products before I purchased. I would certainly use them again, at least for the PurePlug 2.0, and likely other toys. They have most if not all the njoy products on sale now.
Thanks again, Susie, for the wand recommendation. I heartily second it to any other members. When I'm lucky enough to find a new woman to love and play with (yes, both are essential for me), I'm looking forward to starting the prostate finger massages from her!
Hey, one more question as I have never posted photos to Zity except my avatar. If I wanted to, say for example, post pictures of the PureWand and PurePlugs for members to see after reading this post, where is the best (only?) place to put them?
Eric