Pants lowered or all the way off for spanking?

Having my "ER" pull my pants and underwear down to my knees is the best for me. They usually slid down to my ankles while I'm over her knee.

Of course, everything comes off for what happens after my spanking!

I have no idea why, but my preference is always to take a woman's pants and panties down to their knees before taking them across my knee for their spanking. There is something visually appealing about seeing a pair of panties stretched across the knees.

I think it is very important to spank in layers so you should start either over the pants or the panties and have them lowered from there as the punishment or play progresses. If you take the pants all the way off it ruins part of the anticipation and doesn't frame the butt as nicely while the Spankee is over the lap.

I prefer pants down but not removed. Maybe that's because growing up spankings were administered that way.

For my bare bottom spankings. It really depended on the spank-er.. If it was my mother she would have me take my pants and undies down to my thighs and get over her lap. If it was my step-Dad he would undress me for embarrassment and then go over his lap. I never had the choice. I liked it better knowing I could pull my pants and undies up after mom finished making my butt bright red with her oval oak hair brush. So I guess pants lowered was my choice eventhough I didn't have one.

I received my first naked spanking over my wife's knee on our wedding night. She showered first, then I and took me by my handle , walked me over to the bed, sat down and over her knee I went. A few moments later their was a knock on the door "housekeeping, I have your extra towels". My wife told her to come in. She stopped in her tracks when she saw us both naked and me over her knee with a pink bottom. While they talked, my wife didn't miss a beat as she held me down. The housekeeper said she'd leave the towels on the dresser, "no my wife told her, please put them in the bathroom as I'm a little busy right now". She passed within 6' of us on her way to the bathroom. Upon leaving, she turned to my wife and said "hope you have a good evening" and said to me "you too sir, it was nice meeting you", then smiled as she closed the door. My wife then put me on my back on the bed and told me to pay homage to her naked hiney with kisses and biting before mounting me in a 69 position to our mutual satisfaction.

"housekeeping, I have your extra towels". My wife told her to come in. She stopped in her tracks when she saw us both naked and me over her knee with a pink bottom.

Every time I read about a naked encounter with hotel housekeeping, maids or staff, my mind automatically goes to the media sensation of Nicholas Sarkozy getting into more legal and media trouble than he could handle in a lifetime.

Luckily it didn't cost you the presidency of France ... ha ha ha

I usually get spanked fully naked, stripping in front of the spanker is part of the process. Presenting my bare bum for a thrashing plays into it-- I know if I kick my legs or resist I have to start again and take twice as many licks...

I'm diapered full time so the equivalent for me is being spanked with my diapers on or off and I find that those actually have different meanings for me.

Being spanked with my diaper off is being warned that I'm seriously in actual trouble. I never used to take spanking seriously and I always used to find it more sexy than anything but I think something about being in diapers has put me into a little more babyish headframe and being spanked with my diapers off is something I fear.

Being spanked with my diaper on, on the other hand, is usually a way of covertly saying that I can fix whatever trouble I'm in by 'servicing' the person spanking me.

I do not get paddled often at all---and its with in a very good marriage---For certain conduct with my male friends of which my more religious wife strongly disapproves--it means a bare paddling----no question of pants coming down as I just get it right out of the shower---so I just automatically bend right over and hold my shins and get my naked butt paddled---It hurts--but then things are fine between us----When a paddling has to happen I want to get it right away----which is fine with my wife---so it happens asap!

Any other guys want to get it over right away?

Always down bare bottom, sometimes pants off, sometimes completely nude. Does ever remember being spanked with anything covering my bottom, except a swat while out in pu license and I knew that meant when I was taken home that my pants would be coming down, and it wasn't going to be a pleasant experience.

I prefer my girlfriend to take her pants and everything down to her knees and no further. That makes sure her entire backside is bare, up thighs, sit spot and bottom, which are thoroughly work over targets. I have her take each layer down separately and not until I tell her too. This is where I began to lecture her before I order to push a layer down. It's about obedience and surrender her fate to the discipline spanking also.

She has to prepare herself as a sign that she too is being a part of process and as outward communication that it's consensual. I even have her prepare herself from the other side of the room so she has to shuffle over inch by inch. It's help prepare her psychologically for the reality of what's going to happen and what she is consenting to let me do. She needs to feel the humiliation, the anticipation, the trepidation before the actual butt blistering she is about to receive.

Also, I often use a stepping stool and I left her up and place her over my leg dagging from both ends. But she always has a pillow to bite down on, push her face into to muffle her screaming. Its just a turn on for me to see her britches still on but pushed down to her knees.

When I spank my husband I prefer to pull his pants down to knees.

I like standing in the corner with panties around my ankles

It never actually depends on me. I was always spanked /paddled/whipped on my bare bottom whatever it was with my pants and underwear lowered just to expose my ass or to my knees/ankles or fully nude.

When I am spanked my pants and underwear are lowered to my knees.

My wife like to pull my riding breeches down to the tops of my boots (knees).

I get teased by my male friends, but I wear boots and breeches almost every weekend around the farm.

I realy prefer t pull pants and undies down to mid-thighs or knee level before going over knee, i really appreciate this view and i think it add a sort of formalities which are good for spanking.

I think it's even more shaming struggle with panties overloop somewhere around your legs than nothing at all.

But i always do baring because it show that spankee lost every power.

I agree with you entirely, its much more embarrassing to have the pants and knickers lowered (perhaps even having the knickers taken down after being taken across her knee) rather than taken right off, is a much more traditional and affective way to be spanked. And, as you say, when around the knees or ankles, the pants and knickers act as restraints and ensure that the spanked will not get very far, if he gets off her knee and tries to run before she's finished.

When I was married to a Middle Eastern lady, we had a ritual for making up after an argument. The one who admitted more guilt would have to stand in the living room (we always checked the curtains carefully), and allow the other to undo his/her belt and then pull down pants or skirt along with underwear, to the ankles. The one giving discipline would sit on our sofa, and gesture to the other to hobble over and lie across his/her lap. The guilty party would then get a bare-bottomed spanking. When I was on the receiving end, "Yasemin" would always pull up her skirt enough that I was lying across bare thighs. I loved it as much as she did, and the feeling of my bare penis getting hard against her thigh as the swats fell, was a special treat.

The discipline didn't end with the spanking, though. The guilty party, still with red and bare bottom out, genitals visible and garments around ankles, had to kneel in the middle of the room. The other would stand with his/her back to the offender, and lower his/her own pants or skirt, and underwear. The guilty party had to kiss and nuzzle the other's hips and ass, until s/he said, "You're forgiven."

When I was the one kissing Yasemin's ass, I loved to steady myself by holding my left hand on her pubis and pubic hair, using my right to spread her cheeks.

When Yasemin was the one getting the spanking, I always made sure to have some Vaseline ready to smooth across her hips when the spanking was finished, and she liked me to dip a little into her rectum, too. (My pleasure.)

I think we sometimes started fights on purpose, just to make up!

My husband either starts on my pants or panties, depending on what I wear at the time.

Sometimes I get a few sharp smacks, sometimes he takes my panties off and gets me good 😃

But I love when he catches me naked and starts on nothing but my bare butt. My favorite for sure!

Growing up, I had to take my pants and undershorts off for a spanking. Now, I generally expect my spankees to do the same. Naked from the waist down just feels right to me.

Honestly, I prefer to lower my submissives pants/undies, either to the knee or ankle. I’ve spanked before with the pants completely removed, and wouldn’t pass it up if I was presented with that opportunity again. Hell, I’ll even spank with pants and/or undies still on.

When I'm spanked I like my knickers pulled down, from anywhere below my butt to above my knees. My spanker can do this while I am over his knee, which is a plus. Don't know why I find knickers being pulled down so hot. Maybe because I associate it with parental spankings.

I agree with this first post and others who say around the knees making you squirm and struggle more. This is way better than pulling off or making the spankee take their panties all the way off.

My jeans taken to knees while standing in front of the spanker, between his legs. He begins "the lecture" of why he has to spank my bare bum as he lowers my panties. Still being told off, I must stand at his side (embarrassed that he can see nearly everything already) As the lecture is ending and I'm maneuvered into position over his lap, SMACK, SMACK, SMACK as he decides I'm not sticking my naked backside up prominently and in easy range for him. A few more smacks before he potions me so my head is too close to the floor(in my opinion) and he says that's a better view of " my everything," my words not his. Then the spanking commences with the hairbrush to my bare bum. If I'm lucky, I'm doing the awkward spanking lap dance for a few minutes before the embarrassing hobble to the corner, if it's going to be a more severe spanking, he has me stand so he can remove my outer clothing (though the shirt is usually gone, as he says it's in the way and easier to get over my head while I'm in spanking position.) He lectures more as I stand nearly naked at his side, often adding that I must be enjoying my punishment as I've become so wet. He puts my panties back up near my knees so he can watch me struggle during the next (hopefully final) part of my spanking. I dance over his lap and my panties get closer and closer to my ankles and I embarrassingly expose much of myself to him at his satisfaction, ...

Now I'll add that about 25-35% of that was embellishment for your entertainment, with the beginning being more factual and the ending/middle (I never said that that next phase was the end) but the end of th post may be more exaggerated or fanciful.

I have posted on this previously but having recently experienced being taken over the knee, my bottom rubbed while I am being told why I “need” to be spanked, a few smacks to my clothed bottom then having my pants and panties slowly lowered to just under my cheeks, that first rush of cool air on my bare bottom, then the actual spanking.

Something about only my cheeks being exposed and feeling my pants just beneath them, its like a reminder that I was naughty and he is giving me the red hot bottom that I need.

My pants were always pulled all the way down to my ankles, and my underwear was the pulled down all the way. I would have to stand there and then if my shirt was covering any part of my butt, it was removed. Sometimes during the spanking I would kick my legs and my pants and underwear would fall off.

Just lowered is embarrassing unless all clothes come off

Well I like pants and seeing guys in pants so I tend to leave them on as long as possible . When peeled down I often leave them round thys or knees . I think it looks more humiliating that wat. Depends on guy , type of underwear , moods etc