Do you prefer a pacifier or your thumb to suck on?

For me it depends what type of mood I'm in. Some days I like to just lay there and suck on my thumb and think baby thoughts and other days I think of sucking on a binki when I'm pretending my mommy is changing my diaper

I like sucking on a pacifier. I prefer a bottle when i am being changed!

I really enjoy a bottle and then a paciifer during changing and naps.

This baby girl much prefers her pacifiers,but if I loose my pacifier then my thumb ends up in mouth!! I also nurse 2 bottles a day of my Similac formula(which I love).

Neither one for me. Those are poor substitutes for the real thing.

I'd much prefer to suck on a big soft boob.

Pacifier it much better it doesn't mess up you teeth up as much

Personally, I prefer my paci to suck on. But I am not always able to suck my paci when I want to (such as when I am out in public or using public transport) & at those times I tend to find myself naturally sucking on my thumb, without even realizing it.

I've tried to suck my thumb it just doesn't do it anymore. To nasty and foreign to me. I'd have to stick to a pacifier.

I prefer my thumb, it's natural and organic.

For me it's the binkie, hands down. I have a pretty good assortment of pacifiers. To me they scream baby I love that. Also, I've tried the thumb, but it just tastes funny.....

A pacifier

Never likes the paci....my mom did say i was a thumb sucker till i was about 6 years old for some reason i have no memories of that lol

Neither one for me either. The important thing to remember is that the pacifier can get lost in the middle of the night.

Pacifier

Pacifier

When I feel in a baby mood , I like to dress in a frilly dress and rubber pants , and suck on my pac.i, while i watch tiny toons on my video machine

I love my dummy/pacifier i don't like to suck my thumb i get told off if i do

Binky all

the way. My thumb tastes funny.......

Pacifier only

I like a pacifier that way my hands are free so I can play with my dolls

Pacifier! I do suck my thumb as well, After being away from my pacifiers for 10 days, I could not believe how good it felt to again be sucking on my pacifier!

In my case prefer my thumb till about age 6 or so, but Why not both? why choose when your can enjoy both? ?

Binkey loves his binky,not his thumb. Thumbs get all pruny when they get sucked on!

Pacifier is best for me

Paci, by a long shot (although my thumb will help me sleep if I can't use my paci for whatever reason).

I've always had a nervous habit of sucking and chewing on my fingers, often to the point of developing blisters. My paci saves me from that. Obviously I also feel more babyish when I have it, but that also makes me feel more centred and comfortable.

Personally it has to be my binky...

Thumb gets all shrivelled and gross amd I find it really uncomfortable to try and relax I end up suffocating with my hand over my noes.

so Binky is definitely the one. Guess I've never been into suckling my thumb

Pacifier! My thumb if I cannot find my binkie ! I really like sucking on my binkie when I am wetting my diaper. Also when diapered, watching cartoons, I wanted to drink my coffee from my Ba Ba but it took me 3 times of taking my binkie out of my mouth & putting it back in before I could keep it out long enough to suck on my Ba Ba!

I've been sucking my thumb all my life but, with the onset of sleep apnea, I have to wear a CPAP unit. I got the nasal pillows as their construction allows for sucking my thumb while asleep, but it didn't work as well as I'd like so, for the first time, I used an adult sized pacifier and it worked perfectly. With a chin strap, it stays in all night and my air leakage went down to almost zero. My fiance totally understands and, because my snoring is cured, encourages it. In the daytime, usually while driving, reading or watching TV, it's my thumb. But at night, the pacifier works just right.

Note, too, I'm not an adult "baby". For me it's pure habit.

I prefer my pacifier to my thumb I use it every day at home or round freainds

I much prefer my paci's as they are is safer and much less prone to germs. I keep one on a ribbon clip with me at all times as I find it very comforting and reassuring. Using a paci is much better for one's teeth too, I think.