Almost any toy that can find its way into my anus or rectum. This is not a joke. Hard (currently sitting on a 1.25 lb stainless steel njoy PurePlug 2.0), super soft (just put in my Square Peg Egg plugs first time yesterday), or anything in between (Tantus Ryder, etc.). I love them all. Even after two enemas today of 4 then 2 quarts, I still wanted to be plugged again ASAP after the enemas settled down. And I'm seriously considering another enema tonight, followed by re-plugging for sleeping tonight. I'm definitely a serious anal and toy enthusiast, like I have been since about age 15, now 64++. Happy New Year, plugging friends.
Eric
Addendum: I did take my third enema of today just now, a record for me at 3 in a day, plus an even bigger record of a total of 8 quarts over the day. When I expelled just now, I was absolutely floored (flushed?) to discover some really substantial solids still coming out, which I guess atttests to how well my small bowel emptying is still working despite 8 quarts of flushing distal to it. As I alluded to above, despite 3 enemas over about 16 hours amounting to 8 quarts of flushing, with a large stainless plug held in between enemas (njoy 2.0), I'm still ready to be plugged again shortly for bedtime and overnight.
I did mention above that I've been pretty much an anal addict since about 15, now almost 65. So to snswer the OP's query, yes, just about anything that I can maneuver into my rectum, hard or soft, solid or liquid, AOAP (as often as possible) for as long as possible. I'm not sure what I'm plugging myself with tonight, but I'm thinking of a new super soft Square Peg Egg plug I just received yesterday. I still have a couple of larger softish experimental plugs about 2.5-2.8" that I'm gradually working on getting in, but still in the homework stages.
Tonight I think I need something soft and soothing like the SP super soft Egg plug after putting my anus through 8 quarts of flushing! If I should manage to push it out into my underwear overnight, I'll probably switch it to a Tantus Ryder which is very comfortable, a good prostate stimulant (I hope I can still sleep!) and firmer so less prone to push out. I frequently sleep with that one in and forget it's in when I wake up until I need the relief. I can't wait.
Happy New Year, plugging friends.
Eric
Dick