Do you prefer Long or Fat Toys

I prefer fat, even better if it has multiple sizes, like the blue bubbler or Anal Stimulator.

For myself I prefer LONG over Fat--- Preferred toy being a flesh coloured 14" Doc Johnson...Business end being approximately 9"long X 1&3/4" diameter, tapered flexible shaft with 3 graduated marbles.

Said toy provides superb internal massage either by deep short movement or LONG smooth strokes.

However with that being said & as with many here who also enjoy the wonderful pleasures of anal play,naturally have a range /selection of implements at my disposal for the more expansive interests.

I had three I use to have a lot of fun with. One, highly flexible, about 14" long, 1" diameter, it slid up like going in a double door garage! LOL

I had another that was very soft and flexible, about 1 3/4" diameter, about 12" long, it had a nice head on it, it slid right into me and easily right up into my second sphincter, I could feel it slid right in, I could almost cum just from that. Squatted on the floor, knees on the floor, greased up, put it on my asshole and slowly rocked forward and backward, I was always amazed at how easily it slid right up me and into my second sphincter. It was hot!

And another that was about 2" in diameter, about 8" long, it slid in rather well too, I use to like the fullness.

And, I had a fist which I shoved in a number of times.

When moving once, because of my situation, I had to get rid of my toys, I miss them. Then I started anal estiming, so hot, that's where I am today. An electrifying experience! LOL!

I prefer long with an inch to and inch in a half in diameter. I like to feel it sliding in way up.

I must admit, i can go to about 1.75" diameter and then it becomes work to get in my anus. I do enjoy longer toys-had about 3/4 of a double-dong inserted a few times once I was cleaned out and relaxed-gave a very enjoyable stuffed feeling.

We like both. short one, thin and thik, and soft long one.

one of our favorit is this:

http://www.fetishzone.net/store/elypse-art-equinox-si-equine-dildo-p-1408.html

A very nice toy for strapons, soft, able for full insertion, and the best, you can give derp enemas with it.

here a second one we love:

http://www.lovehoney.co.uk/product.cfm?p=8657

short, thick and you can give or take enemas too.

I like the long feeling but the stretch is often times a good feeling to so id have to say long with a nice thick base to really stretch the hole

Yes prefer long rather then fat.

Sometimes I like the long toys for depth, but I love the fat ones for the stretch. It all depends on my mood.

Like them long and textured for maximum stimulation ... fun to go in and out..

Long is good, double ended for two to enjoy, is better.

I prefer long over fat. A regular size dildo 6-8" long is just great for a good ass fucking. UMMMMMMMM!!! Of course after a couple clean out enemas first.

I prefer fat over long. There is really something about the thickness and the extra pressure on my prostate that makes me enjoy that over length.

I would take fat over long any day because I would get a good stretch from a fat toy.

Long over fat because once inserted, my anus gets accustomed to the narrow base. When removing, it really hurts no matter how slowly I try to remove it.

My vote is LONG and about an inch in diameter

I agree with Dug. About an inch in diameter is just right, and as long as I am able to tolerate. Some flexibility greatly aids in increasing depth of insertion.

I like them long and fat. I used to have a soft dildo that was about a foot long and probably about 2" in diameter, and very tapered and soft at the top. I would kneel, knees on the towel, dildo against my asshole well greased and slowly push backward while leaning forward. It went in nicely and felt so good, and I could feel it slowly and gently going into my second sphincter. It, was a very filling experience for me. Then, I would rock back and forth and eventually cum while giving my dick slow strokes. My bottom felt so well filled with that dildo.

Long toys are great most of the time, but fat is a nice alternative sometimes.

I like the stretching caused by fatter toys - to a point. I don't like pain.

Long, as pain is not what i am about...deeper the better.

I tend to gravitate toward the deep side. I'm not opposed to fat, I just can't take really fat toys. And yes, I have been called a "tight ass" before 😃 Anne Thrax is my hero.... (Thanks Anne)

David

I am slowly converting to fat instead of long 😃

I like long, but also like to explore and try different sizes, shapes.

Reading all this stuff leads me to try longer (for the moment I use fat plugs).

The question I have is how to pass with a long dildo up to the sigmoid colon?

Is there a preferred width of dildo for this?

Do you have any advise?

How deep have you been (without the dildo bending in the sacrum)?

Idk if i have had enough of either to even decide, I'm on the fence at this point, no pun intended haha

I like 3 to 3.5 inches after a series of enemas.

I like them both, and a combination of long and fat is a very nice feeling. My choice depends on my mood at the moment.

Even 7" is too long for me, for I cannot put it in its full length without it hurting. A 1-1/2" diameter nozzle is as big as I go.

hankb

I prefer longer-medium girth is ok but i'm not into stretching myself out. Largest comfortably tolerable: 1& 1/2 " thick x 12-14" long. My sweet spot: 1"x 8-9" long (toy) with an interesting head shape. (love repeated penetration/insertion)