Which is a better enema-the Fleet or the Bag?

The red bag!!!

I've come to the conclusion that neither the bar nor the bulb is better! It all depends on the situation. For a solo enema session the bag or my Jones irrigation can works best and they continue to look highly erotic to me. For a session with a friend, however, the bulb syringe ranges supreme! The multiple insertions and the "surge" are fantastic. I can't imagine anyone NOT enjoying a bulb syringe enema.

If the bulb is large with a big tip it can be lots of fun. But for more serious play look to hang a 5 qt red bag with an inline flowmeter, higginson pump, and ramp type clamp.

When you refer to a "squeeze" type enema, you are talking about a disposable chemical enema, like a Fleet. These solutions do cramp, because the chemical is a strong irritant to the bowel and therefore induces a strong peristaltic action.

If you want to use a disposable Fleet-type squeeze bottle enema, I'd suggest the newer Fleet Naturals. They are intended for exactly what you are talking about, clean-out before play.

If I want a short bowel clean-out, I use an 8 oz. bulb syringe of tap water, or a fountain syringe bag with no more than one pint of tap water. This will clean the "playground", without sending you back to the potty on several trips, later.

Deffinetly I prefer a full bag, fleets are way to harsh for me. If I just want to feel clean and fresh, a fleet naturals works great, can hold that forever.

I have given and taken Fleets on numerous occasions but am convinced that the best enemas are given with the old-fashioned enema bag. There's no rush and the enema can be administered gently and lovingly. The contents can be adjusted to the reason for the enema: soapsuds, salt and soda, or just plain water (warm or cool). Same for quantity: a little or a lot as the giver chooses.

Enema bags rule!

The very best is the good old reliable SS enema given while lying on the right side. Give it slow and hold it. Its the best.

The bag. The only good enema is from the bag. That little bottle is a poor excuse for an enema.

Each have their place depending on your needs. For a quick wash out a couple of Fleet's will do the trick. If your constipated and need to get everything out that is deep inside your bowels then a two or three quart bag is needed.

The best is obliviously the bag for the quantiti of the , fleet work just for a little bowel movement, the bag is the best cause really flush all colon so....

The bag/can naturally. Fleet only if pressed for time and/or traveling.

I vote for the bag every time, now if Fleets were 2.5 litres with a flow control valve and a big nozzle???

The bag defintely wins, hands down. I have always found the Fleet enema to be less effective and far less pleasurable than the bag.

I'll take a bulb any day. Not into volume, it is the repeated insertions that turn me on.

Love 'em both, But a bag with a Higginson attachment is the best. When being done by my wife, it allows me to take the quantity I want while she can squirt me on occasion as she plays with me in so many other delicious ways!

My wife administered a Fleet enema to me after coming home from the hospital, a few months after we got married. I layed in complete misery waiting for that thing to work for over 3 hours. She finally decided to use her green 2qt bag with douche nozzle on me to get things moving. I love getting enemas, but that one was very unpleasant because I was so screwed up from the Fleet. I felt like I was going to explode before she pulled the nozzle out. Talking about relief when it was over, but the bag enema would have been easy to take if she'd done it first.

The Bag is always better it gives a more efficient enema.

No question...the bag wins in every respect as this knowledgeable group has recounted. Not only are Fleets uncomfortable and irritating...they are impotent. Why waste time and money on such a product? I do however, make one exception...when traveling or visiting I keep an empty Fleet Extra bottle in my kit; filling it with warm water for a quick 'spritz' to soften things up until I can get home to a good old bagfull.

No contest. I don't think of the fleet as a "real" enema. They don't do a lot for me either so the only times I take one are in a doctor's office when told to do so and that is the only option.

Fleets are EVIL! The harsh chemicals are awful and about all a Fleets enema will do is help empty, but not truly clean out, the rectum.

Bag enemas are far more versatile as far as solutions go, and unless an irritating solution is used, much gentler.

As the many of my fellow klysmos have stated, there is no comparison between a lousy Fleets and a well given/taken bag enema!

The bag is definitely the way to enjoy to process and get a decent clean out. However, a couple Fleets will have to do before an early morning physical exam that includes the classic prostate check.....

The bag hands down! I wouldn't choose any other!!

Definitely the bag!!!! I f you were on vacation and really constipated a fleet would do, but that's about the only situation I could see using a fleet. If you're taking an enema for pleasure then only a bag will do. So much more sensual. Fleets are very STERILE. It's like the difference between having great sex with someone and masterbating. They both get the job done, but WHICH would you really rather do?

I love the bag for a nice deep clean out. If I want a quick clean out before sexytimes then ill do a couple of fleets.

Definitely the bag. The only question is; which one!

For quicky anal play, the Fleet. For a thorough and relaxing time, the bag.

I couldn't find a bag when I first wanted to try enemas 2 years ago. I got a disposable one. Yes, the disposable DOES work, but I agree Julie, it was not likeable for me. Caused a lot of cramps - enough that I almost didn't continue looking for a bag. But I found a $5 set at Walmart, figuring that I hadn't lost much money if I didn't like it. Instead, I found the bag was very enjoyable, and here we are!!

I have only had a bag enema once when i was little for constipation from a doctor and it hurt like crazy im assuming due to the amount of liquid which i took (i think it was like a litre or 1 1/2 lites or something) and that i was constipated for 2 weeks didnt help me out much. But every time i have tried the squeeze type (bulb) enemas, i have found that i take them a bit better as i just do what i feel i need then stop to release in the loo.

I despise the ready made squeeze ones. The cause cramps that seem to last for hours and hours. Definitely the bag is better!

The bag wins, by a mile !