What is the best way to spank to create a stinging pain with no bruising?

In response to Intruder regarding being spanked in a girdle to minimize bruising, I think is accurate. I love wearing retro girdles (mostly open bottom ) complete with nylons held up tight with 6 garters. When spanked over my husband's knee, it does offfer some protection but it also seems to hold the heat in pretty well and after awhile with continued spanking by hand, paddle, or hairbrush, the sting begins to really light up my bottom and it stays lit up for what would seem a longer time. That being said, I still look forward to when I deserve and get a proper spanking in whatever state of dress or undress that I might be. 😃 Denise

@Denise while a heavy satin panel girdle may offer protection I find that I tend to spank the recipient harder. Paddle or hairbrush. I also will after a while will undo the back garters on an open bottom girdle and spank bare butt until good and red. Then lower the girdle to hold the considerable heat in.

Hope you don't have a desk job. Thinking of you 😉🌹❤️

A slipper on the bare bottom does the job nicely.