On one occasion, when my sister was having a slumber party, my friend (he was also spending the night) and I tried to pull a practical joke on the girls. Our attempt to have some laughs at the girls' expense went seriously sideways, and we found ourselves in BIG trouble when my dad said, “Okay boys! Your asses are grass, and the girls are going to watch me mow the lawn!” First, my dad spanked my friend in front of the girls (one of whom was that friend's older sister). Then it was my turn.
My dad had put my friend over his lap wearing his boxers, so I thought that I would also be allowed this degree of modesty in front of this group of girls (even though I had ALWAYS been spanked on-the-bare).
When I walked over to stand next to my dad (without removing my boxers), he said, “Aren't you forgetting something, young man?” And I said, “Sir, please don't make me take off my boxers in front of the girls!” And he said, “I'm not going to tan your boxers! They didn't misbehave! YOU misbehaved, and YOUR BARE BUTT is going receive your tanning!”.
After I had been punished, my friend's sister asked my dad, “Mr. Smith, why did you spank Johnny's boxers? They didn't do anything wrong!” All of the girls giggled. And my dad asked, “Jane, does your dad spank Johnny's bare bottom?” Jane answered, “Yes sir." And, at this point, my mom (who was standing nearby) said, “It's okay, I know Johnny's parents very well, and Jane is right. You should make sure that he also doesn't sit comfortably for a few dsys!” And my dad said, “Okay Johnny… get back over here!”
After my dad had properly tanned Johnny's hide (on-the-bare), my sister spoke up, “Daddy, it isn't fair that Johnny received two spankings and Jimmy only received one!” My dad agreed, and took me back over his lap to even things up!