Wood or Leather: What one hurts the most for you? I hate anything wooden small or big,,,

Definitely wood. It doesn't give.

Wood hurts like kwazy

Definitely wood. It doesn't give.

You want something that doesn't give? Try carbon fiber. I use golf club shafts.

I like to use a soft leather paddle with feathered edges so it does not cut in. I can apply it until a girls bottom is just the right shade of pink/red and she is crying and begging me to stop. If she is being punished I will then switch to the bristle side of a hair brush and paddle her until her already red backside is covered with red dots. If she has not voided before the spanking most girls will start to pee when the pain is too much for them. That is a good time to stop and apply soothing lotion very gently until her bottom is still stinging and sitting hurts but she can get control of herself.

My 12" leather paddle with a smooth side and a suede side gives the best flexibility and strength to get the tears flowing without really traumatizing the bottom or leaving marks and welts. Long spankings with the hand or a light weight paddle of this kind are more effective that heavy handed harsh spankings which tend to put the guy getting spanked into a state of shock rather than sustained distress and discomfort. Most guys say that they like it better than either wood paddles or leather belts.

Leather does get guys up quickly makes them unable to stopped being made fully aroused.

Wood! When its swung hard enough not a lot of swats are needed to really sting a deserving bottom.

I liked answer number 12 below, "Ping pong paddle I thought was the worst. Wood I think is more hurtful in a bad way, leather more hurtful in a good way (if that makes any sense)..

A very lightweight wood paddle used properly will get a bottom dancing, but I prefer a bottom bright red with minimal marks...so small leather paddles works quite well.

Wooden brush handles

For pure unadulterated sting it is Lexan. Oh My God!

To me, much of the experience is the sound. Wood reflects resonances of the material used in the fabrication of the paddle, or whatever. Leather, on the other hand, has a distinctive sonic signature that conveys the essence of exquisite pain. Even hearing the strap used on another brings tears to my eyes.

I think wood is probably the most painful instrument. With the right combination of flexibility, length, width and thickness a wooden impliment (or synthetic material substitute) can be be unbelievably painful with incredible stinging on the surface.

I agree with many of you, how its being administered and the type (thickness & size) can change a lot on how it feels. Most people I've played with would say that the wood implements are worse, and having tested them I can easily see why. If you find something stingy easier to tolerate I think you would most likely find most leather implements easier to tolerate (unless you using something heavily weighted like susie mentioned.) While some wood paddles can be stingy (especially if they are smaller or thin) a lot of them tend to be more "thuddy" and I think it is harder to tolerate - at least for me!

Personally, I find something that stings easier since (at least for me) the sting can fade pretty fast.

Asking which hurts more is comparing apples and oranges.

[color=#ffffff] . [/color]

There are other variables to be considered besides the materials the weapon is made of.

Some wooden paddles are very severe and some leather paddles are very severe-especially the hard leather ones weighted with lead shot.

It depends on the sizes and shapes of the paddles.

I can beat the crap out of you and give you black and blue marks and make you bleed with either type.

Wood every time. My mothers oval oak hair brush made quite an impression on my bubble butt growing up. Today it's my solid oak paddle.

Just got a new 12 inch wood paddle today. Gave myself a few swats got a good sting to it. Can't wait to try it on my Sweetie.

My mother and step father always used a leather strap or a leather belt on my brother and I. It was usually with panties down and in the presence of the other parent, and my siblings. When I was in high school the assistant principal used a wooden paddle that hurt more than the leather strap. I was sent to a private school for my last two years and there the head mistress used a switch and for really bad offenses, a cane. The cane was wicked. I only got it once but I tasted the switch plenty of times. Now I am in my late 20's and married to an older man who has a young teenaged son. I share in the discipline and when he is to be spanked I generally use a strap or a belt. I stopped doing it over the knee when I discovered that he almost always got a hard on when I spanked him. Now I make him bend over a chair or lie on his bed with a bunch of pillows under him to get his butt high. He prefers to have me punish him because his father is way more severe.

When I am being spanked I find hurts me most . Wooden implements will get my backside bright red an warm rel fast .

Wood is probably more stingy but a nice leather paddle will put a slow warm on a bottom and keep getting hotter. It is also not as noisy in a hotel type setting

I think both can be made to hurt like hell, but a heavy paddle like a frat paddle has a jarring effect I find really unpleasant.