Jessica, that shows the importance of thinking through your idea and putting it as completely as possible when you post. It makes a big difference to know you already had a scenario in mind rather than the general idea of having someone break into your house and tie you up in reality. I would not have realized it was fantasy had I not looked at your profile.
I chose not to remove the thread last night because I thought it still might go somewhere, and I was going to keep an eye on it to be sure members played nice.
I've been thinking about it, and wondering what the appeal is, not simply to your question, but those who fantasize about any violence directed at them. I haven't thought as far as rape. I don't want that even in a fantasy. But I've thought about what it would be like to have my partner take me as he wants, whether or not it's what I want or when I want it. No violent force, but firmness, pushing force if necessary. "This is what we're doing." I would be okay I think because we would have my safe word in place, and would know I could trust him to back off or stop if it became too much in any way.
I think it comes in part from my sub-ness, the desire and need to relinquish control. That's why Miss Stress wavers in her position on the matter - She is Dominant. I think the other part of it comes from having had a partner who had zero interest in sex. I wanted him to take charge, to show me he desired me. To take an interest, initiate, and unless I had a real reason not to participate, to take me on occasion. To show me his leadership, that I could follow. But he was (is) even more sub than I am, and I think he hates it. That's another thread, though, or a blog, perhaps.
What do y'all think? WHY do we fantasize about this sort of thing? FANTASY and PLAY, not reality, so don't even go there in telling us how horrible it is. That's not the topic. You can start a different thread about that if you want.