Hello, perhaps I'm only supposed to reply to the OP??
My wife tends to be passive, but greatly enjoys any physical attention to her body - that is, with the exception of her rectum and anus. I had hoped she'd get over it, but many years have passed with no change in sight. I've always bent over backward to avoid causing her any discomfort. She's even put off by the gentlest touching on the outside.
She twice suggested anal copulation (and seemed to tolerate it well), but I suspect she had ulterior motives for keeping me away from the other area.
I'm a man of modest experience, but I've never come across another woman who didn't love to have her ass played with. And I've read that this is the norm.
I've always loved making (and buying) "furniture" and sundry devices to expose my wife's vulva and subject it's innermost parts to excrutiating pleasures. She has never complained or objected in any way, and has often said how much she enjoyed this or that particular procedure.
For some strange reason, at this point in my life, all of my lust is directed toward my wife. It drives me crazy that I can't have my way with her ass, but I don't really want anyone else's.
Sometimes I think she's turned off by the possibility that some small amount of excrement may find it's way into the picture. But she's equally adamant in her opposition to enemas, and (as I said) any stimulation of the anus, even when no penetration is planned - even by the most delicate of instruments. I love to require her to spread her buttocks until the anus is beautifully exposed. Even this she finds very difficult. She doesn't like to call attention to it in any way.
For me, on the few occasions when I've had my finger inside, it's been the most heavenly experience. Once, when she was asleep, I was able to insert it fully without waking her. So, you see, it's not a question of discomfort. Only plain stubbornness.
Do you think her bahavior is anomolous? Or am I doing something wrong?