Looking for butt plug recommendations....

I've got lot's of different butt plugs, but I'm not completely happy with any of them. I'm looking for one that I could keep in for very long periods (days to weeks) of time, only removing for bowel movements & washing up. The thing is that I want as much stretch as possible in the neck area of the plug, while still being able to have good retention. I'd like at least a 2"-2½" diameter neck. It also needs to have the ergonomic shaped base that fits comfortably between the cheeks. It's not to be too long either. It seems like any plug that goes too deep causes too frequent urges for bowel movements. Silicone seems to be the most comfortable for long wear.

So.... what do you suggest?

Square Peg toys might be the best place to start looking. I've gotten several different models from them in the past & were happy with their products. I recommend the Egg Plug for longer wear comfort.

Https://www.peepshowtoys.com/collections/peepshow-toys-booty-toys-entire-collection/products/oxballs-ergo-super-soft-silicone-butt-plug

Agree with @Just AI that SquarePeg Eggs are great. The OxBalls one you call out is also a good choice.....they are made in a very similar way and have a common feel. They work well for long term wear and accommodate the wearing of a thong if retention is a concern

Have a look at ToppedToys. I’ve a couple of their toys and they’re pleasantly soft and well finished. I don’t use them for long term wear but for more intense play sessions.

Nonetheless, this one https://toppedtoys.com/products/lotus-120 or one of its smaller brothers might meet your needs.

Have fun.

Look into squarepeg toys plugs, specifically the "Blunt" family and "Splitter 2.0". I'd go with supersoft silicone for long term wear.

This is my favorite plug. It comes in different sizes, silicone, very comfortable to keep in for awhile, and tends to rest right on my prostate.

https://www.extremerestraints.com/products/premium-silicone-weighted-anal-plug

Lovense plugs are great anal and vaginally

They are remote controlled so you can share experience with someone

When you wear them, you can be surprised anytime

I actually saw today that they sell butt plugs in CVS- in a whole section of sex items such as lubricants, pills to stimulate arousal, etc.

I have recently added 3 plugs to my anal toy collection. Here is the link on Amazon:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08JV8M16V/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

They come in 6 sizes (I have the medium, large and Xtra large plugs), so you can choose the one or ones that would work best for you.

I am not sure how these plugs would do for long term use, but I can say I have kept the medium size one in for about an hour and it did not come close to falling out on its own. These plugs are made of silicone and are super smooth. They do have some flexibility making them easy to insert. They are easy to clean up after use. Being silicone, I have found they do not irritate the tissue at my anus or inside my rectum, so they would seem to be a good choice for extended use.

Along with these 3 plugs I have and 3 other training toys ranging in size. Here is a link to a pic in my gallery:

https://en.zity.biz/index.php?mx=gallery;ox=showalbum;ax=13828

Let us know which plugs you decide to buy. Hopefully you will find that perfect plug. It does take some trial and error.

I think XR171 has the best recommendation for a good long term plug. Especially the long t shape base. The other plugs are probably good too but I had a bad experience with a plug slipping all in once and just don’t want to go there again. I especially enjoy long term wear as in all day and all night and prefer the slender stem that letsvmy ass grab on tight.