Soft silicone butt plugs

Ok, question for you all. I'm not as advanced as most here, but I do wear a small silicone plug from time to time. So here is my question, has anyone ever had the base half break off? Is it the lube I am using? I have used a water base and I have also used coconut oil. Is it cause I have such a huge ass and these plugs can't handle? Is it simple cheap material that makes them break?

I'm asking this cause I have had 3 break on me it's usually one of the arms holding it in. Two I used water based lube with, the last one I used coconut oil. Any advice would help

@Lookslikebetty I've never had one break on me. I only use a small amount of KY, sounds like inferior silicone to me. You could always buy a glass or steel plug to eliminate the problem. Happy plugging! 😉

@mike45 I have two metal ones, I like the weight of them very much but the heads on them are the big jewel and hurts my buttcheeks after awhile. Currently shopping for a metal one that has a longer neck and slimmer base.

Thank you for your response

@Lookslikebetty Anytime Hon! 😃

In 30 years of playing, I have never has a silicone plug fail. It is possible that if there was an air-pocket in the casting or possibly the formula wasn't mixed correctly... Silicone is fairly bulletproof so I suspect you had a pug that wasn't actual made of silicone - TPU or a low-grade pattern material perhaps.

@mike45 I have two metal ones, I like the weight of them very much but the heads on them are the big jewel and hurts my buttcheeks after awhile. Currently shopping for a metal one that has a longer neck and slimmer base.

Thank you for your response

Hi lookslikebetty the njoy plug has long neck and they come in four sizes. I can wear mine all day long and go to sleep with it in.

That's what I am wondering since I ordered them all from the same company

I've tried over a hundred different silicone plugs (not exaggerating), some of them for extended periods of time (8 hrs+) and never had this happen. Even with some of them being over 7 years old. It would be helpful if you could mention which particular plugs you had this happen to.

Water-based lube shouldn't be a problem.

As for coconut oil, I am not sure. I've googled it and some sources claim it's perfectly compatible with silicone toys while other sources claim it can degrade silicone material over time, causing it to break down. What I do know - it sucks as lube.

No, I never had one break. I have my big silicone butt plug in me right now and I'm sitting on it in a chair (towel on the chair too). I had it for several years and stick it up my butt almost every day. Its has a wide base too. Hope to get a lot more use out of it. Got it on Amazon.

N-Joy make perfect ones.

@mike45 I have two metal ones, I like the weight of them very much but the heads on them are the big jewel and hurts my buttcheeks after awhile. Currently shopping for a metal one that has a longer neck and slimmer base.

Thank you for your response

N joy make perfect ones.

No real silicone plug has ever failed on me in all the years of playing.

I'd suggest to look at https://www.squarepegtoys.com/ for quality soft silicone plugs.

Happy plugging!

I am not an avid butt plug user since I have yet to find that elusive "perfect" plug for me. That said, during my search, I have found plugs of differing quality and workmanship. I have found a couple in my collection that I have had to throw away. Fortunately, none have broken in me while inserted, I always carefully inspect them prior to use and have noticed cracks and dry rotting along the stem on a few of them. They get tossed out immediately. My preference is for a smaller slimmer plug with a narrower stem, I am guessing that has something to do with durability of that part of the plug. Sadly, some of them were my favorites at the time and so the search goes on.

Agree with comments above re inferior merchandise and manufacturing. Have several prostate massagers made of silicone from a reputable brand and have never had any problems with any of them! You may pay a bit more but the quality is worth it!

No real silicone plug has ever failed on me in all the years of playing.

I'd suggest to look at https://www.squarepegtoys.com/ for quality soft silicone plugs.

Happy plugging!

I’ll second this suggestion for looking at SquarePeg silicone plugs. Specifically, I have 2 of their SuperSoft Silicone Egg plugs and use both sizes frequently, often for many hours at a time or sometimes overnight. Their home page is

https://www.squarepegtoys.com/product/egg-plug/

I don’t recall the size names of the two I have as it was several years ago and occasionally their size descriptions change, but my larger one has a max diameter of about 2.5”. They give you detailed metric and English size information, usually for Height and Circumference. If you don’t find the max plug diameters listed, just divide the circumferences by Pi = ~3.14159 (can’t find Greek letter pi symbol). Other questions, just write back. Have fun.

Eric

Lubes and silicones - water-based is cool. Some "water based" lotions have emulsifiers that "match" the chemical properties of the silicone and will cause it to soften on the surface or retain an odor, no big deal. Vaseline - no problem. Vegetable/plant oils are fine as well.

Anything that contains silicone (silicone polymers or silicone esters) will very slowly dissolve most silicone based toys. This shows up as swelling and color deformation and is worse on softer toys. My squishy silicone cock/ball-rings that I like to layer on get softer and softer and will eventually tear if I use silicon oil as lube. Too bad I have most of a 55 gallon drum of it!

I agree with the community assessment here. The silicone reaction from lube which causes damage clearly starts out as surface damage, not fault lines running through it. I suspect the breaking is the fault of the manufacturer. Either poor manufacturing quality control of the injection mold flow analysis, or poor material formulation.

I have had good luck with the series of “Snug Plugs” made by B-Vibe.

https://www.bvibe.com/snug-plug.html

Swipe through the photos and you will find a comparison chart of all the sizes. These silicone plugs have a metal rumble ball or two in the center which provide a bit of internal wobble when you walk, and also makes it a touch heavier than just solid silicone. The two I own have held up well for multiple years, and show no signs of cracking.

I agree with hookejoe. The snug plugs are great for long term wear and last forever. I have both the #3 and 4. I can comfortably wear mine all day and frequently all night. The shape helps them go in and most importantly the slender stem makes retention easy. The t shaped base snuggles up between my ass cheeks and gently teases my ass externally and keeps it from going all in. Very comfortable to sit on all day and very erotic to squeeze and squirm with it in at night.

Also they have a vibrating version that will drive you nuts. About 8 different modes and intensity. The only problem is they are a bit expensive but my ass deserves the best.

PipeDream Products make silicone butt plugs in a huge variety of sizes from extra small to mega under the brand Analfantasy. I've owned three for years using a variety of lubes that are either waterbased or coconut oil for lube.

On Etsy-- Lucious Playthings offer handmade all glass plugs that range from small to XL and are fantastic for long term and overnight wear. Also Afternine suggestion is a great one for safe silicone and comfortable anal plugs.

Currently I'm enjoying my XL Rosebud Lucious Plaything. It offers a curved shaft with round base. They also offer flattening the base or a T-shaped handle.

If those plugs bit the dust like that I'd guess they aren't a true body safe silicone toy

I have never had a problem with silicone plugs failing for any reason. I just wish I could find a modest size one that strikes the right balance in having a 'neck' small enough in diameter to prevent the plug slipping out yet being thick enough to keep my anus nicely stretched. I hope that makes sense. I also love the sense of urgent fullness of an inflatable plug gives but they are much more difficult to wear secretly out & about.

So here is my question, has anyone ever had the base half break off?

Oh yes, my fear on using a large one - that it would get stuck up inside you should it break😧

@alan20cm the plug that doesn't slip out is the one that has a nice bulb to neck ratio - the wider the bulb than the neck, the easier is to hold in - but the neck has to be long enough to "clear" the sphincter so the bulb gets inside behind it. Such plugs do not need big bases, as the sphincter is not squeezing on bulb and pulling it inside. Such plugs are also most comfy for long term wear.

In my experience, stretching outer sphincter was never a "problem" - I had much more "work" to do on my inner sphincter, so I always preferred plugs with wider bulbs and do not care much about the neck width. However, even my plugs with neck wider that 2 inches do not stretch that outer sphincter that much to be really felt, as the bulb is wider and takes the show.