What was it like to use a butt plug for the first time?

I wore my first butt plug in my house the night it arrived with the help of my very good friend, I applied a lot of lube, I was a little bit scared at first and it hurts a little bit at first but at the end it was fun and erotic, the feeling was amazing. It was a great experience. I felt so good that I had to sleep with that night, pulling it out and in all several times to make it more comfortable.

Since then I have been sleeping with my plug every night. I feel empty when I don't.

I bought my first butt plug in June, 1983 At a seedy little ABS in southern Indiana. I was nervous as could be, and I am sure the counter lady recognized my first time activity. I was about 45 minutes from my hotel. while driving I opened the package and examined my new little flesh colored toy. At the hotel, check-in seemed to take forever with my new first sex toy in my suit pocket. Once in my room, my only thought was to get naked and lube up my toy. It felt huge that very first time, but I quickly adjusted to it. Next road trip, I was in the market for a bigger plug.

Was amazing! The first toy I ever bought for my ass was a Dildo (I did write a blog about it…) however I soon discovered butt plugs were really my thing. My first one was a medium Doc Johnson, was amazing to put in and i have been hooked ever since.

My first but plug was inflatable and had so much fun with it and guess it started me on the journey of increasing stretch and gape in my ass to eventually leading on to self fisting and double fisting by female playmates.

I was very slow in my play at the first stages and enjoyed the feelings of pumping up and releasing over and over.

I have wanted a butt plug for as long as I can remember.

I had a girlfriend in college who would stick her finger up my butt while giving me a blowjob - which is probably when this desire started.

Sadly -- my marriage is pretty much sexless -- and what little there is -- is very vanilla.

My wife would freak if I suggested any anal action to be performed on me.

With that in mind -- everyone in the family (except me) went on a 1 week road trip.

I decided -- this is the time to do it.

My wife has location tracking enabled on my cell (mostly to know when I leave work, and will be home). I can't leave my cell at home, because I am an escalation point at work -- and this is a work phone. If I disabled location services -- that would seem suspicious.

With that in mind -- I couldn't easily go to a sex shop to buy one, nor order one online (credit card charge history).

But Walmart now sells a small selection of adult toys -- so I drove up to Walmart - cash in hand, to buy a Hello Cake Tush Toy.

I went through the self checkout (it didn't flag for any verification -- so no interaction with store personnel).

I came home -- ripped open the box -- read the instructions, and was crestfallen when it said "step one: charge for two hours" -- that was the longest two hours of my life.

121 minutes later -- I lubing up that toy, and sticking it in.

I cant remember the last time I was ever this proud of myself (for both the purchase, patience while charging, and insertion).

To answer the original question - what was it like the first time.

Bliss . . .

It took more effort going in than I thought it would. Getting around the flange at the bottom was more difficult than I thought.

It thought I had plenty of lube on it . . .but alas I needed more.

I waited till it was inserted -- to turn it on.

I loved the vibrations.

I edeged for about 20 minutes - then finally came.

When I did come, it was the largest volume I have ever had.

Family will be back tomorrow -- guess I need to get one last day of play in before they return.

My ex-wife and I used to take turns playing doctor and patient. When my turn to play patient I was given an open back exam gown and told to strip naked and put it on. She changed into green scrubs top and bottoms. I was called into the exam room and told to bend over the exam table. With her feet my legs were moved very wide apart and she untied the middle exam tie and the gown opened completely. She took the exam gown front and hiked it up on the table out of the way. At that point I knew she had a completely perfect view of my spread ass and my dangling stiffening penis and balls. She announced it was time for my prostate and penis exam. With a very lubed finger she entered my tight anus and went straight for the prostate gland rubbing it caused my erect penis to leak pre-cum some. She grabbed a surprise for me and it was a Doc Johnson Butt plug that was 5.5 inches long and 1.75 wide and said that was the final part of the exam. She ordered me to spread my bum cheeks wide apart as she lubed my anus with gobs of Vaseline and lubed the butt plug too. She inserted the tip and kept advancing forward to the point it was at the widest point 1.75 inches. I said it couldn’t possibly go any further in and she started masturbating my penis like downward milking a cow with the big butt plug still in my anus part way. She stunned 😧 me and shoved the rest of the plug in with one hard quick shove. The pain of it going in shocked me but that stretching pain caused me extreme pleasure too as she was jacking me off causing me to cum violently all over the floor. I was ordered by her to kneel down and clean it up with my tongue 😜 till she was satisfied the floor was spotless.

Exiting. Just the thougt of having a plug inside was cool. The first i tried was a medium size, remember it sort of pop in place after some work to get it in, then the feeling of it stuck in place by the bace, while my rectum kept clenching to get used to it.

It was over 30 years ago when I relocated to California 6 weeks before the rest of the family, I bought an enema bag right away and also wanted a butt plug so I found a place and visited. I was quite horny at the time and selected a larger vibrating plug. That night I had an enema on the couch then tried the plug… it was far larger that I realized but I persisted… it took some time and that last little bit just didn’t want to go easily… in a fit of passion I gave it a push and it went in with a wince but it was in… and it felt real good holding that enema. Once I settled into it and relaxed a bit I turned on the vibrations….. I damn near melted… I caught myself moaning out loud…. It was a next level experience and I loved it. I came hard and a lot. For the next six weeks in that apartment I enjoyed it most every night… only having difficulty that first night. After that, altho still a challenge, it went in a lot easier. It is a memory and experience I’ll never forget.

I was in my thirties when I tried one for the first time with first hubby

It was a small rubber one - thin and longish - maybe as thick at it's widest point as a thumb and as long as a middle finger. Advertised for beginners.

I didn't love it. Not much of a feeling on penetration and when it was all the way in, it just felt like I had to shit. Maybe a little burn-y.

I tried a jewel plug for the first time with 2nd hubby when I was about 50. This was also a medium but it felt ENTIRELY different. First it was more acorn shaped - so a pointed ball that penetrates you with the stem and then the base/jewel. It gave me a good stretch going in, like hubby had to work it in and it hurt a little at its widest point, but a good hurt and then WHOOOP it's like my asshole sucked it in. Like literally SHOOOOOP. Happily the base stopped it, but I was afraid I was going to swallow the whole thing and wind up in the ER.

Hubby moved it around on me while going down on my clit and it was heavenly.

Taking it out was a little bit of a chore as I didn't want to let go (not on purpose). When it did come out, it made a literal 'pop' sound that killed the vibe for me. Hubby was laughing his ass off. I've since learned how to relax and push a little to help it out so we don't have the 'pop'.

I don't like deep anal stimulation, but I do like wide in my hole so this is a good choice for us.

Over the years, I have engaged in assorted anal play, but the first time I used a plug designed to stay on was a couple years ago. It was actually designed and made by me, though not initially intended for use. For some sort of joke at work, my wife has me model and 3D print a butt plug for a coworker gift. So I made an average sized "traditional" butt plug, initially made from rainbow hard filament, which served it's purpose as a gag gift. I had flexible filament laying around, so figured that would be the perfect way to try it out, so printed another. One late night after a couple drinks, the idea came up for us to try it out, and I was the "chosen" one. Bent over, my wife warmed me up until I was able to take it. The diameter was a little bigger than I expected or was used to, so it took a little work. Once in, I enjoyed the continued stretched feeling, but quickly because accustomed to it. I left it in through the rest of our play and intercourse, then a little more. Overall, it was enjoyable. After recalling this, I may have to print another!

@Jimmybobo Is the print resolution small enough for the plug’s curved surfaces to feel smooth? Or do you do any post printing treatment? Sanding? Heat/melt?

@Hookajoe The print resolution is fine enough that the steps are visible, but not rough. Finer detail could be achieved, but I didn't initially have plans to use it. I'm sure some post processing could make it even smoother. Regardless, I just put a condom over it since the material is at least a little porous.

It's been over 2 years since I started using butt plug and I love it. It feels so good in your ass it fills it up. Walking around with it in is fucking amazing with your ass being so sensitive you can feel it in every step it makes me wet. The stimulation drives you wild you end up so horny every moment you feel it hitting some sensitive spots. You can feel your pussy throbbing fighting the urge to find a quiet spot to make your self cum. I always love wearing it to parties it feels good when I dance. It's such an intense orgasm using a buttplug.

I have three Butt plugs that the wife and I have used for several years now, two are flesh colored and one is a small chrome plug with a big jewel, this is my wife’s favorite and will ask for during our play sessions, the other two are softer plastic, one is small, maybe the size of my thumb and about 5 inches long, I have tried this one but it won’t stay in , the wife also likes this one but after a while it falls out of her as well, the second one is my favorite it’s about 2 1/2 inches at the largest point and takes a little while for my wife to get it in me but when it gets past the largest point my butt seems to suck it in fast and it hurts for a second and then my butt feels very full and very good.

The first time I was plugged I told my wife witch was my gf at the time I wanted to try it and she told me once it was in it was to stay in. She then gave me head. I came so much. That was the only time I have been able to get off just from head.

It was actually quite good once I'd gotten over the fact that I was doing it in front of my girlfriend- it was at her insistence to start with but I'd often come home from work and plug up before she got home...

A wonderful feeling of being stretched open and fullness

My first one was large enough to be somewhat painful and wouldn't stay in without being held. It was a fail. I have tried a couple of others and have had better results. I have not found one I thought was just right but liked enough I will try a different one.

A slight burning sting on insertion followed by a wonderful sense of urgent fullness which subsided to be replaced in part by a sort of stretched itching feeling in my rectum. Oh yes & a raging erection that required relief & being only 17 years at the time I nearly had to clean the ceiling!

I love anal stimulation for as long as I can remember and it is probably why I did not raise much of a fuss when mother began giving me and my sister @Lora_C enemas when we were growing up. When I became sexually active after puberty I was afraid of becoming pregnant and oral and anal sexual intercourse were my go to sex acts at that time.

It took my joining zity.biz to really become interested in butt plugs and things to insert into my anus and rectum. My first real butt plug was a set of three silicone anal training butt plugs ranging in size from 2 1/5 inches long by 1 inch wide at the bulb to 4 inches long to 1 1/5 inches wide at the bulb with necks and a stem or neck capped off by a rounded piece to keep the butt plug going all the way in. I had no problem whatsoever in inserting the butt plug into my anus and rectum because I was and will continue to see anal sexual intercourse. I did feel and the stretching of the plug being inserted into me and how it 'seated' into my rectum once past the bulb.

I use plenty of lubrication either on the butt plug when I am inserting it myself or by a lube shooter with the lube shooter being used in me by either my husband or my intimate friends I have made here prior to insertion of my butt plug. Since that first set I have bought or been gifted several more butt plugs and anal jewels which I frequently 'wear' around the house or when going out for dinner or shopping.

The stainless steel anal jewels do have some weight and it does help with Kegel exercises in keeping me or helping to recover anal tone after play. I have also purchased a set of six Kegel exercise weights that I use with a condom. The weights are primarily designed for vaginal use which I do use them for but I also employ them rectally as well.

Some girls at school discussed them so I became aware that way. As a teen I was afraid to have any toys b/c my mother might find them. One weekend when my parents were away I tried using a carrot in my bottom so that was kind of my first butt plug.

My first time using a plug I was excited and nervous at same time. When I went to the adult bookstore ( sex shop ) my eyes were bigger than my hole. I got a 6 inch long 2 1/2 wide normal flared base plug and a bottle of lube. Got home and waited until that evening to start my anal journey. I rubbed lube on it and pressed the tip to my awaiting and excited hole. I gave it a push and the tip entered a little and felt amazing. I thought this is going feel so good, boy I was surprised when I got another 3/4 in and the pain started from being stretched more than I’ve ever been. I held it there for a bit thinking I could still get in in, after awhile I gave up, and pulled it out washed it and put it in my drawer, cleaned myself up and started to rethink my purchase. A couple days later I revisited the sex shop and found a smaller size, this one was 5 inches long and 2 inch wide. Got home and did not wait this time, got naked put some lube all over it and the tip quickly found my exit hole, gave it a push and was surprised how much further I got it right away. I put more pressure on it and it kept going and opened me up, the pain immediately came back but I got further than last time and was determined to get it in. Took a couple deep breaths and pushed hard and it slipped in and muscle clinched around it as the widest part got sucked inside me. The pain was intence but at same time felt amazing. I did not move for a few minutes and when I did it immediately got pushed out. At that point I knew I was going to love having my butt full and played with.

It was quite interesting to say the least