Things to lube plug with for punishment

So far I've found that lubing a small plug with fresh Vicks vapor rub or toothpaste can be a great way to punish a sub… or myself--especially good when combined with paddling, sort of a pseudo-figging.

Hot sauce is of course too strong to subject the rectum to it, and soap just has a laxative effect. Any other thoughts on irritating/painful lubes that are punishing to hold in your ass?

I find vicks to be a comfortable sensation. Not painful at all. Don’t know if there’s adverse effects if inserted vaginally, it’s hard to wash off. It does say for external use only, but I think its widely used on anal toys.

Oh god yeah the only thing i can think of is would be vicks or heat rub and oh god that would burn sting and make my ass hurt like hell .

I like toothpaste. Gives me a nice slow burn.

I like toothpaste. Gives me a nice slow burn.

Never tried that but other posts reinforce toothpaste as a nifty mild irritant.

One could try ginger paste of which most Asian stores will carry, ginger oil or ginger extract, or buy some ginger in the produce section, peel, shape into a plug, score the sides and insert with only water as a lube. When the heat dies down, just work it around some more and it will heat up again.

Here is a nice description of what it feels like for woman, https://rebelsnotes.com/2013/07/i-tried-figging-the-execution/

Ginger is nice. Its effects die off pretty quickly once removed. Never heard of ginger paste. Might have to visit an Asian market. 😜

@VermouthEnemaKatie

Try searching the Topic /thread . . .Vicks Vaporub as a lube. . .and. . .Vicks

There you will find a number of recommendations

I was having a hard time sleeping plugged and read this thread and thought toothpaste might be interesting and now my hole is so warm. It has helped me to relax my hole but I am so so aware of it. I should not have done this because I still must stay plugged until breakfast or sir will be disappointed. It has now gone from hot to cold and I am barely aware of the toy buried deep in my bottom bc I am so focused on the burning cold of my hole.

I recommend liquid soap 🧴 gives a stinging burn in the ass and you really want to get rid of it if you are not into anal soap play 😈

Definetely shows a sub their place 😁

After reading this post, I checked the bathroom cabinet for some Vicks. Lucky me! I took a Q-tip full and inserted it in my ass. WOW! What an incredible burning sensation! Now I get to go out and sit on my lawnmower for about a hour and a half.

There are lots of things that will give an irritated or heated feeling to the anus and rectum. Individual sensitivities vary, so experiment with very small quantities and much care.

A Q-tip dipped and re-dipped in liquid hand soap or body wash used to paint the plug.

A Q-tip dipped and re-dipped in Dr. Bronner's peppermint castile soap, same.

A Q-tip wet with a liquid dishwashing detergent used to paint the plug, the Q-tip wet with water to spread it farther if needed.

A pea-sized portion of mint toothpaste.

A smaller portion of cinnamon toothpaste.

Powdered ginger mixed into gel-type lube. (Ginger paste is going to end up mostly on the outside; it won't stick.)

Vicks, as mentioned above.

Noxema face cream, which contains eucalyptus as a mild irritant.

A sprinkle of cayenne added to lube or Vicks, if you dare.

I see a lot of you had the same experiences as my siblings and I did, Vicks, ginger paste, soap sticks, just about anything mentholated, we also got ginger suppositories with a plug dipped in Vicks or something similar, and we got plugged with a ginger fig sometimes.

I see a lot of you had the same experiences as my siblings and I did,Vicks,ginger paste,soap sticks,just about anything mentholated,we also got ginger suppositories with a plug dipped in Vicks or something similar and we got plugged with a ginger fig sometimes.

Hello Gretchen !!

Thank you for this comment !!

I would think, all of these things, you have talked about, are very rememberable in your mind !! - am i right ???

Kindly greetings from Germany !!!

I have no idea what it would do in the ass, but an ex of mine, lovingly and with the best of intentions, coated my scrotum with IcyHot once. That got a lot hotter than either of us expected. If anybody decides to try it in the ass, let us know what happened please.

I have found soap to be punishing as a lubricant; I suppose I am not opposed to it's laxative effect.

Sometimes when I know I need an enema for self-discipline I use a homemade punishment lube I make on myself first (this usually causes enough burning and irritation that the enema is necessary and therefore is somewhat of a practical way to "force" discipline upon myself).

The recipe for my punishment lubrication is simple-Mix freshly ground ginger powder with liquid glycerin until the correct consistency I am trying to achieve is produced-then apply liberally and swiftly to my bottomhole to place myself in the position of "point of no return".

My glycerin ginger lubrication does of course have a laxative effect, which I believe OP is trying to avoid, however, I figured I should drop my reply in anyway for those who may be interested in a recipe that works for effective discipline, self-inflicted or otherwise.

I see a lot of you had the same experiences as my siblings and I did,Vicks,ginger paste,soap sticks,just about anything mentholated,we also got ginger suppositories with a plug dipped in Vicks or something similar and we got plugged with a ginger fig sometimes.

I am curious to hear about others' ginger suppository/soapstick recipes and procedures.

Holy mackerel Gretch (Post 13). We had the leather strap, leather belt, switches and such taken to our skin for being bad dudes but what you experienced is very memorable and would make a very interesting, not to mention, erotic conversation.

Ive used muscle rub oil/cream, dish soap, tide pods, toothpaste, teeth whitening gel. The muscle rub cream I used actually dilates your rectum pretty wide. Its a vasodilator and i swear by it. Although the things listed does have a laxative effect, it feels good to me.

I use a nettle plug coated with vic on my sub- he squeals with delight as i twist it around

I know this is not a lube for a plug but when I gave myself an enema once I put a bar of Dr bronners peppermint soap half in my butt and went in and out a lil bit before continuing my enema and wow it burnt Soo fucking good hehe. I usually don't like burning like that but that time it actually felt amazing!! It was like it was just the right amount of burning not to cause too much pain.